Cookies help us run our site more efficiently.

By clicking “Accept”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy Policy for more information or to customize your cookie preferences.

LISTEN: Maria Jose Talayero Schettino on using her research to advocate for environmental justice in Mexico

News Feed
Wednesday, July 17, 2024

Dr. Maria Jose Talayero Schettino joins the Agents of Change in Environmental Justice podcast to discuss why she switched careers from physician to environmental health researcher, and how she’s using this new training to advocate for environmental justice in Mexico. Talayero Schettino, a current Agents of Change fellow and a DrPH candidate in the Department of Environmental and Occupational Health at The George Washington University, also talks about the challenges of immigrating to the U.S. and how the medical field can better prepare doctors to understand the effects of environmental pollutants on our health.The Agents of Change in Environmental Justice podcast is a biweekly podcast featuring the stories and big ideas from past and present fellows, as well as others in the field. You can see all of the past episodes here.Listen below to our discussion with Talayero Schettino and subscribe to the podcast at iTunes or Spotify.Agents of Change in Environmental Justice · Maria Jose Talayero Schettino on using her research to advocate for environmental justice In MexicoTranscriptMaria Jose Talayero Schettino 00:00I don't I really don't think high income countries realize how all their decisions impact developing countries.Brian Bienkowski 00:11Hello and welcome back to the Agents of Change in Environmental Justice podcast, a partnership between Environmental Health News and Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health. I'm your host Brian Bienkowski, editor of Agents of Change, and senior editor at Environmental Health News. Folks, we are so grateful for your support. We've been at this a few years now and we would love to continue to grow. Please share this podcast with your family and friends, colleagues, and subscribe to us on Spotify or iTunes and please leave us a review. Today's guest is Dr. Maria Jose Talayero Schettino, a current fellow and a doctorate pH candidate in the Department of Environmental and Occupational Health at the George Washington University. Maria talks about switching careers from a physician to an environmental health researcher, using her research to advocate for environmental justice in her native Mexico and how the medical field can better prepare doctors to understand the effects of environmental pollutants on our health. Enjoy. All right, I am now joined by Dr. Maria,Jose Talayero Schettino. Maria, how are you doing today?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 01:14I'm doing great. Thanks for having me here. Brian, how are you?Brian Bienkowski 01:18I am doing wonderful. And I'm really excited to hear about all the work that you're doing. But I want to start at the very beginning. Tell me about growing up in Mexico City.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 01:29Oh, yeah, I honestly have very good memories about growing up in Mexico City. But I'm not sure how familiar you are with Mexican culture or if you've ever traveled there, butBrian Bienkowski 01:41almost zeroMaria Jose Talayero Schettino 01:42Mexicans really highly, highly value things like hospitality, generosity, respect for elders, solidarity. And it might sound really funny, but we highly value social connections and gatherings. I mean, it's weird to say that we really value parties, but we do. And that's why our food and culture is so important. So I feel like growing up in Mexico City was just like that: full of culture, tradition, family gatherings. And I feel like I'm very lucky to be able to call myself Mexican.Brian Bienkowski 02:12Is there a certain food or or holiday or gathering? Are there certain ones that kind of stick out in your mind as being particularly poignant?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 02:22I mean, yes, I think so. Particularly, Independence Day. I have very good memories about going to watch the fireworks. Independence Days in September. Most people in America think it's Cinco de Mayo. But that's not it. It's in September. But other holidays that really stick up for me are the other mortos which is in November, and also Posadas, which are held during like, December. So Christmas is very important to us too.Brian Bienkowski 02:54And the only thing I really know about Mexico City, and pardon my American ignorance, is it's it's a massive city, right? I mean, were you in kind of a dense urban area?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 03:04I mean, yeah, it's a huge, huge city. And I feel like there's a lot of people living around Mexico City, I did feel like I lived with my family in one of like, more suburban area, not closer to like, the historical center or anything. But we travel a lot by car. I mean, we have a huge air pollution problem because of that. But I feel like yeah, it's a huge city, and everyone's all around it in. I mean, it's very, very well connected when it comes to streets, we have a lot of traffic, but that's how people go around Mexico City by staying in traffic for really long periods of time.Brian Bienkowski 03:48So how and when did you become interested in health and the environment?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 03:53I mean, this is a great question. And every time I get it, I wish I had that story, "like when I was younger, I used to tell my parents that I wanted to be a doctor since I was a little girl." Unfortunately, that was not me. I wanted to be a singer. I wanted to be an artist. I wanted to be a painter. So that was not me. So I think I ended up in like healthcare and the environment because I really loved science. And don't get me wrong, I really hated physics and math. So because they hated it, I feel like that drew me into chemistry and biology. And I I think I ended up in medical school because of that, because my love for science and honestly, I never knew I was gonna end up doing research and doing a lot of statistics. Even after I ran away from math.Brian Bienkowski 04:42The only class I ever got to see in growing up was chemistry that that that for some reason that subject gave me such fits. And I don't know if it was my teacher, or what but it really bothered me.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 04:54I mean, yeah, it's a really, really hard, hard subject! and I I feel you I feel like I just don't know, I don't know what it was. But chemistry and biology always caught my eye.Brian Bienkowski 05:05eye. And the weird thing is now I, you know, I've spent most of my career writing about chemicals in the environment. So it's, it's strange, I hope I'm not just writing a bunch of incorrect things.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 05:17I guess I guess you've made peace with it. And now you love it.Brian Bienkowski 05:21That's right. So before we get into your your career has been fascinating because you, you started off in healthcare as a physician, and I want to talk about your journey. But first, what is a moment or event that has helped shape your identity?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 05:35Wow, that's a really hard question. I think there are a couple of things that I want to mention that really shaped my identity as I was growing up. And I feel like the first one was really practicing medicine in public hospitals, that really showed me that life is not fair. And that made me want to work on that. And I think the other thing I want to mention that really shaped my identity is immigrating to the United States, even though I emigrated when I was, I think, 26 years old. Even though I'm like a short four-hour flight away from home, I think immigrating made me realize about all the things that I took for granted, and now I really highly value.Brian Bienkowski 06:16Luckily, we're going to talk about both of those things. Because I think that's, it's a really important part of your journey. And starting with this idea of you became a physician in practice in rural communities around Mexico City. So can you tell me about this work, what you learned from this time with patients and why ultimately, you decided to switch careers?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 06:34Of course. So I guess, practicing medicine in rural communities, and even public hospitals, or public health care centers in Mexico, it really does feel like an art. Because you need to learn how to treat disease differently. Sometimes the medicines that you learn on a book that were the best for a specific disease are not available. So you have to work around it. And the same comes for like diagnostic diagnostic tools, you don't have fancy equipment, or even sometimes you don't even have basic equipment to make a diagnosis. So you have to really focus on talking to the patient. And that's the only thing that you often have, and you have to learn how to practice medicine with that, which is the only thing that you have. And I think when it comes to the change that I made from like, a very clinical-practice-based career into like an research and an environmental one is that one of the things that frustrated me that most while I was practicing medicine is that there were and there are still a lot of things that we do not have answers for in patients. When they come to get a diagnosis, they sometimes ask you were themselves like why something happened. And most of the time, we really have to say that we don't know why. I think there's even a medical term for this, which is that something it's adiabatic, which means that we have absolutely no idea what costed and I really hated it. I hated not being able to have answers for my patients. And I mean, I still don't have all the answers. But I think as I moved forward into an environmental health career, I realized that this field of environmental health had a lot of those answers. And that through my medical education, I barely heard of those. So I think that's what made me shift.Brian Bienkowski 08:18So we're going to talk more about your your research and that switch. And, you know, maybe some ideas you have for the medical field to bridge some of these gaps. But I have to ask, did your did family and friends question your decision? I mean, being a physician is a is a career that I think most of us know. I mean, we all know that career. It's familiar to us. It's a pillar in most communities. And I think researcher is a little more esoteric to a lot of folks. So I'm wondering if your family was like, What are you doing?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 08:48Oh, my gosh, yeah, I every single person that went through medical school with me or even my family, or even friends, or even now that I meet people, when I tell them that I went through medical school and that I became a physician. Now I do environmental health, every single person has questioned that. And I feel like sometimes, when like for the Mexican perspective, a lot of people questioned this because they don't really know much about the field, and how important it is. But I don't know like having all these people question your life decision makes it like just harder to move forward and harder to realize if you're in the right path. And I think that was really hard when I first made the decision to switch. But now looking back, I don't think I would do anything differently.Brian Bienkowski 09:38And to keep on this theme of challenges. I want to reflect a bit on your move to the US. You mentioned how important Mexico City and family and gathering was to your, to your upbringing and identity. And I don't know that most folks understand the toll of immigrating even under positive circumstances like yourself. So can you talk about this experience and what people should know about the personal channel changes and sacrifices for immigrants?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 10:02Yeah, honestly, thanks for asking this questions. I think that sometimes the challenges for like immigrating in good, some good circumstances, like I did is invisible to others. But from my experience, I really want to say that immigrating in good circumstances to the US is extremely challenging. There are so many rules and steps that you need to take that often really don't even make sense and can really make your life harder. But I do have to say that I'm really fortunate to be here. And I'm really grateful to the US for the all the all the opportunities that I've had. But moving away from family is so hard. Like you move to a country where you don't have this support system, the culture is extremely different. And you need to talk and communicate using a different language. I don't know if you've watched Modern Family. I really like that show. But there's this episode.Brian Bienkowski 10:54Modern Family? Yeah, gosh, yes. I'm a yes. I'm rewatching it right now. Yes.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 10:59I love it. I love it. But there's this episode, where Sofia Vergara says, "do you know how smart I am in Spanish?" And it's so funny. But it's so relatable. Like, there's so many things that I want to say, but I just cannot find the words.Brian Bienkowski 11:13Well, thank you so much for sharing that. And I want to talk now about the work that you're doing as you've made the switch to research. So you're examining environmental exposures, and birth defects in Mexico. That's one of the things you're working on. So I wanted to talk about talk, you know, if you can explore this link between these exposures and birth defects, why it's concerning, and who is most impacted?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 11:34Of course, yeah. So through my dissertation, I'm on the final stages of my doctoral program, hopefully graduating this August. But through my dissertation, I've been studying birth defects and their relationship that they have with the polluting industry in the country, in Mexico. It has been challenging to do something like this with public databases that the Mexican government has, but I found really interesting things. For example, I've seen that the reporting for genital birth defects in Mexico in the last couple of years has been steadily increasing. I mean, this could be due to so many things –like people know now how to recognize them better or many other things. But when you compare that to other countries, this seems to be happening, too. And it's making us think about the impact endocrine disrupting chemicals are having in communities around industrial areas. I think it is very concerning to see the impact that pollution has in your health even before you were born. Like I don't think people realize that we used to think in a medical field that that placenta was like this major barrier where nothing could go through it. But we've realized that that's not the case. And I really think that we don't have strict enough regulations for most chemicals. But overall, like if you asked me like, What was the most concerning thing that you saw is the lack of data that Mexico has for both health effects and polluting chemicals. I'm always amazed that countries like the US, for example, like researchers in the US say that they are so far behind, but they don't really realize if they're far behind where developing countries are.Brian Bienkowski 13:11You mentioned a term their endocrine disrupting chemicals, which I think a lot of Environmental Health News readership is aware of. But for our listening audience, can you explain what those chemicals are? And kind of the plausible ways that they could possibly be behind some of these birth defects?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 13:26Of course, yeah, sorry, I forgot to explain that! But yeah, endocrine disrupting chemicals are generally what we say are chemicals that are capable of interfering with the way your hormones work. And your hormones are very important since the beginning of life, because hormones are also chemicals, but they mediate a lot of processes in your body. So if there's a chemical there's interrupting those pathways, then you can see problems with your development or the endocrine system diseases, for example, reproductive issues, or diabetes, or thyroid problems. So mostly, those are the things that we're concerned when we get exposed to endocrine disrupting chemicals, which are almost in everything. But one of the major things that we know, gets us exposed to endocrine disrupting chemicals, are plastics.Brian Bienkowski 14:21Soyou mentioned gaps in the research. And you noticed this pretty early on that there were some gaps in environmental health and environmental justice data in Mexico. And I know you're just one researcher, but can you talk about this dearth of research and how you're trying to tackle this?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 14:35So I feel like environmental justice has been overlooked for centuries in both the community scale and the global scale. I really don't think high income countries realize how all their decisions impact developing countries. For example, I remember a few years ago, there was this Super Bowl held in Arizona or one of the border, one of the border states, but I think it was Arizona. And they said that they weren't going to have have a zero-waste Super Bowl because all the plastic generated was going to be recycled. But that plastic was shipped to Mexico, to northern Mexico, where plastic recycling plans are polluting the water and air of Mexican communities. So is one of the of the issues that we see in the global health realm. Like, this is not something that only happens in Mexico, but it happens everywhere. But with things like in the country level, when I first started the process to find something I wanted to do for my dissertation, I remember talking to my chair, about wanting to do something on environmental justice. So I started doing research on what was out there. And unfortunately, I wasn't able to find much. And I think this is related to what I was talking about, that we don't have a lot of data. And there's also something going on in Mexico and you know, other Latin American countries like Colombia, where it's very dangerous to be in environmentalist in those countries. Mexico is one of the deadliest country to be an environmentalist. So advocating for these things can get really challenging.Brian Bienkowski 16:03So can you talk about your efforts, in particular to advance environmental health policy in Mexico, including on lead and criminal behavior? And can you talk a little bit about your involvement with Mundo Químico, boy, I'm probably butchering these words. I'm really smart English, I swear. And what have you learned? And have you had any victories along the way in your in your efforts to advance environmental health policy down there?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 16:28Yeah, so let me talk a little bit about what Mundo Químico is, which translates to chemical world because we live in a chemical world. So this Mundo Químico is like a collaborative of scientists and other professionals in Mexico that got together and are really trying to push programs and policies related to environmental health in the country. Honestly, I feel like I'm very lucky to be part of it. I am the youngest member. And I ended up being there because as I was finishing up my master's program, I always felt like I owed something to my country, and I needed to do something in Mexico. So I did some research and who was working on environmental health in the country. And I found this very big and famous scientist, his name is Dr. Carlos Santos Burdoa. He's US-based. He was at the George Washington University, when I first heard of that of him. So I email him. Honestly, I didn't expect a reply, because like, senior scientists are really busy. But I did get a reply. And I was really surprised. But he told me that he was building this collaborative called Mundo Químico, and he asked me if I wanted to join him. So of course, I said, Yes. So what we've been trying to do, as I was saying, is to push environmental health agenda into the policies and to do some programs to reduce environmental health exposures. And we started with lead exposure, because Mexico has a really big problem with lead. I think we've done different things that I don't think I have enough time to talk about during our podcast. But what I have learned, and I think I have learned a lot of things, but one of the most important ones, is that it is so hard to communicate to the public and with policymakers. And I really did not expect that when I started my career in environmental health. And I think that's how I ended up studying lead exposure and criminal behavior. Because often when you want policymakers to listen to what you have to say, you have to talk to them in their terms, and talk to them in topics that that you feel that they will prioritize. So we know crime is a big thing in Mexico. So what we did is where we viewed all the available evidence to see how lead exposure was related to criminal behavior, we found that there's a link. But we still need research on this. And we need research to understand what the relationship means in the Mexican context. But yeah, I feel like that's how it started because we need to learn to communicate with policymakers. And I really don't want to stop talking about this question without mentioning some of the wins that we had, because I feel like in environmental health, we will always hear a lot about our fatals and not our wins. So we have had some wins, we have been able to produce some programs on lead exposure. And one of them is we were able to partner with WONART, which is an Arts Fund that the government of Mexico has and through their through them, we've been able to push this program to train pottery workers to produce lathe, Clay ceramics, which are a major traditional thing in Mexico and they usually have led in it. But we're pushing this program to produce lead-free clay ceramics and to certify that they're lead free. And even though we still have a lot of work to do on that issue, the start of the program to me is just a great win.Brian Bienkowski 19:54You mentioned two things there that I have a follow up on and you started to get to it a little bit at the end is is you meantioned that lead exposure is a big issue in Mexico. And I'm wondering if you can just kind of give a brief overview of the ceramics and potentially other sources of lead in the environment there. And then second, if you can kind of walk us through why there's this possible link to crime, what does lead do to people that could make them more susceptible to committing crime?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 20:20Of course, yeah. So I'll start with at glaced clay ceramics. So in Mexico, we use traditional pottery for cooking, storing, or even serving food. And one of this traditional pottery is called glaced clay ceramics and the glaze that the ceramics have, it has lead in it. And because it's not produced in ovens, that can reach high enough temperatures, in like close ovens, because it's a very artisanal process, the lead stays there, and it leeches into food. And he usually leeches when you like cook, or store food that's very acidic. And Mexican cuisine is really acidic. So it leaves us a lot of lead. And we have a major problem of lead exposure. Because of that, that's actually the main source of lead exposure in the country, because most of the people in Mexico use it. Like if you go down there, you'll see it in restaurants, you'll see your honestly see it everywhere. And the latest numbers show that children from one to four ages in Mexico, 17% of all children from one to four years of age in Mexico have lead poisoning. So it's a really public health issue, we don't have data to see if older kids have lead, we don't have data on adults. But it's a really big concern, because lead is very toxic, like the WHO says that there is no safe level of exposure to lead because of how toxic it is. And he causes a variety of things. It can increase cardiovascular disease, it can damage the kidneys. But one of the ones, one of the things that we have studied the most is how it damages the nervous system and the brain. And this goes back to the question that you asked about criminal behavior. So we've seen that lead damages the prefrontal cortex of the brain, which is in charge of, of behavior, and, yeah, to put it in, like, easier terms, yeah, it's in charge of behavior and how you react to things. So when it damages the neurons there, it can cause antisocial behavior, and it can cause aggressiveness, and it can cause violent behaviors. So that's how we've seen it has associated with criminal behavior. So in addition to that communication work directly with policymakers and residents, I know you're also active on social media. And I'm wondering how you've leveraged those platforms to try to get the word out on some of these environmental ills. Oh, my gosh, being on social media is so hard. I don't know if you've tried it. But seriously, it takes a lot of effort to create content on social media. But yeah, so I ended up in social media, because going back to this environmental justice issues, Spanish speaking countries, and communities really don't have as much information as English speakers do. And that's something I really noticed while I was scrolling down on every social media platform, so I saw hundreds of videos on how to reduce environmental exposures, but almost none, were in Spanish. So I decided to venture into social media. And honestly, I don't have that many followers, my platform is growing. But one of the things that I've noticed is that many health professionals are starting to follow me because they're interested. And they want to learn more, because some of their patients are asking about these topics. So I feel like it's a great way to do outreach and communication, things when you're in the environmental health field.Brian Bienkowski 24:06I have not tried it. Of course, I had I had social media accounts. It's been more than a decade. I think since I've had one, I don't even have LinkedIn anymore. I am really happy that people like you are on them, because I think it is a counterbalance to the reason that I got off, which is a lot of kind of miss information and hatred. But it is really heartening for me to see folks like yourself and scientists in general and health professionals are able to take their message directly to people as opposed to kind of being mediated through, you know, newspapers or whatever happened back in the day. So I think that's a good thing. And we have noticed though, as a newsroom, a lack of Spanish language environmental content and information and we are trying to trying to combat that with some eh en español coverage. So We have noticed the same thing as you. And there is a real language justice issue in the United States when it comes to environmental information. So I hope people will follow you. We will add a link in this podcast article so people can follow you if you want. Having spent some time now in the environmental health research field, and we were talking earlier about how you started as a physician, how do you think the medical field could better incorporate environmental health information for patients and prepare those physicians?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 25:28I mean, I honestly wish health care workers have better training in environmental health. From my experience, which is going through medical school in Mexico, I really can't speak for other countries. I barely heard about environmental exposures as causes of disease, when I was in medical school, maybe I heard about asbestos or silicosis or occupational exposures, but non an environmental exposures like a social determinants of health, which they are. So I'm currently working actually on a project with some peers on how there is a huge gap in medical and other other healthcare professions school curriculum when it comes to environmental health in Latin America. And it is a sad reality that we barely see courses on environmental health in these curriculums. But I can tell you that I like I can see myself advocating about this for a really long time. And I think we need to get to a point where every single doctor, every single dentist, every single nutritionist, every single nurse knows that this exists, and that we need to know about it and talk to our patients about it.Brian Bienkowski 26:41This is purely anecdotal. But I do feel like I'm seeing more on the climate side of things where physicians are being more active and perhaps more trained in climate change and extreme heat, but less so on –surprisingly– less so on things like chemical exposure, and the things that you've been talking about endocrine disrupting chemicals. So hopefully, hopefully, that changes because I think that would be a real public health win. So, Maria, this has been so much fun hearing about you and your work. And I have to ask you, before we get to some of the fun questions, I have a couple more questions. And one is do you plan on going back to Mexico? Would you want to work there? Or do you think you'll stay in the United States? What do you want to do with this environmental health research training?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 27:25Oh, my gosh, you're putting me on the spot.Brian Bienkowski 27:28I mean, you can have a no comment.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 27:30I know my family's gonna want me to give an answer that maybe it's not the one that they like. But I do feel that the work that I'm doing for Mexico in the United States, is far like, I feel like I have way more opportunities to do something for my country from the United States, than the ones that I see that are my country. And it's a really sad reality, because I would give the world to just go back to my family and my nephews. But if I really want to see a change, I really feel like I have to stay in the United States for at least a couple of years. To improve, like my research techniques to get a better sense of what's out there and what I can do for Mexico. I mean, in the future. I don't know how long from from now, I do see myself going back to Mexico at some point. But right now, I don't think it is an option. And it is a sad reality, not only for me, but for other immigrants that are doing science in the United States, because our countries lack opportunities.Brian Bienkowski 28:39And Maria, before we get to the fun stuff, what are you optimistic about?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 28:44Oh, that's a really important question! I feel like we don't hear about optimism sometimes in the environmental field, like there are so it's filled with bad news sometimes. But I feel like I'm optimistic about hearing more people are learning about environmental exposure. So how they can affect their health, because honestly, sometimes social movements can move policies faster. So we really need that. I'm optimistic about how younger generations are thinking more about the environment now. And they're joining this fight. There are so many things I'm optimistic about. And I'm glad you brought this up. Because again, I don't think that this field is full of good news. So we need to, to have these victories and these things that we're optimistic about really present in our day to day because he can get overwhelming at times.Brian Bienkowski 29:37I think the hard thing in my profession and maybe this is true in science in science communication as well, is whenever we try to talk about good news, it often feels like we're perhaps greenwashing or perhaps we're overlooking, you know, renewable energy is a great example. You know, solar energy and wind energy are less polluting, however now we have to go get those chemicals to make those panels in the ground and community. You know, so there's always there's other problems and we don't want to overlook those. But I totally agree with you that we need to be better as a, as a country in general about celebrating environmental wins, so people just don't get so down about it.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 30:17Yeah, cuz I mean, when I talk to people about toxic exposures, I usually get the same reaction, like, everything's toxic, I'm gonna die from something. So I might as well just stop thinking about this. And I don't think that's a great approach. So, I mean, that should go back to our communication efforts, like, what are we saying, what are we doing? And how can we make this better? So our message gets out there, and it's not as overwhelming as it is currently.Brian Bienkowski 30:43100% totally agree with you. Well, Maria, thank you so much for your time. I'm just so I'm so happy to have met you and have you in this program. I'm just really excited about the work you're doing. So before I get you out of here, I have a few rapid fire questions where you can just answer with a one word or a phrase, if I have a whole day off, I am likely.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 31:05Oh my gosh, I'm probably hitting the craft store to find a new craft to doBrian Bienkowski 31:09What what type of crafting do you like do?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 31:12anything, like anything like it, maybe it's knitting, maybe it's stitching, maybe it's painting, whatever, like, whatever is new, I'm doing it.Brian Bienkowski 31:22So my wife and I, we live in the Upper Peninsula. And so we have very long winters. And I find myself this time of year. And I hesitate to even say this pining for winter, because it is such a great time to be quiet. And I play I'm playing music and my wife does be beadwork and stuff like that. Or we do some paintings together. And it's all crafty, and it's cozy and quiet. And then in the summer, I find that I really miss those. I really missed those times. So I need to find a way to do more crafty things, when it's nice outside. Yeah,Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 31:54I can relate to that. 100% I feel like it's a great therapy to do craftBrian Bienkowski 31:58100%. Well, I just had a guest on who was the guest, I'm forgetting now. But I had a guest on we were talking crafts not too long ago, I'll have to dig that out. Because I think it's for folks like yourself who are really busy doing this kind of work. It's good to have that other side of your creative brain get used every now and then. So the best gift I've ever received isMaria Jose Talayero Schettino 32:22I'm gonna see my family.Brian Bienkowski 32:24And if I could immediately gain one talent or ability it would beMaria Jose Talayero Schettino 32:31I know, to be able to get grants for research without being rejected.Brian Bienkowski 32:37Not flight or invisibility, just just grants! this one good for research. keeping it simple. I like that. And you do not have to. You can talk more than one word or a phrase here. What is the last book you read for fun?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 32:53Oh, this is a good one. So lately because I've been working on my dissertation. I feel like I've been reading a lot of science stuff. But I feel like the last book that I read it was, I feel it was last year. And it's a book by a Mexican Indigenous woman, well, Ilfrosina Cruz who is now a representative in the Mexican government. And it's a great book. I'm not gonna spoil it for everyone. But she talks about her life as an Indigenous girl and how she wanted something different. And she wanted to create opportunities. And she moved on to be a representative and changing the laws in Mexico. So it's a really inspiring book, and I highly recommend it, it is called "Los Sueños de la niña de la montaña," which translates to "The Dreams from the girl up the mountain. I don't know if it's available in English yet, but I know it's in Spanish and I really highly recommended.Brian Bienkowski 33:46Excellent. Well, Maria, thank you so much for your time today. Thank you for being part of this program, and we'll have you back soon.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 33:51Thank you. Thank you so much for having me. It was a great talk.Brian Bienkowski 33:59That's all for this week. folks. I hope you enjoyed my conversation with Maria. If you enjoyed this podcast, visit agentsofchangeinej.org. And while you're there, click the donate button to support us or sign up for our free monthly newsletter. You can also find us on X, Instagram and follow us on Spotify or iTunes and never miss an episode give us a rating. This agency chain podcast was recorded written produced and edited by me with outreaching scheduling and support from the rest of the team Dr. Ami Zota Dr. Yoshiro Cornelis Van Horn Dr. Veena singlet, Dr. Max on Dr. Laura Edwards, summer Ahmad and Maria Paula Rubiano. Our music is now sung by Paddington Bear. Thanks for joining us. We hope to keep these important conversations on diversity in science and health. Go. Have a great week folks.

Dr. Maria Jose Talayero Schettino joins the Agents of Change in Environmental Justice podcast to discuss why she switched careers from physician to environmental health researcher, and how she’s using this new training to advocate for environmental justice in Mexico. Talayero Schettino, a current Agents of Change fellow and a DrPH candidate in the Department of Environmental and Occupational Health at The George Washington University, also talks about the challenges of immigrating to the U.S. and how the medical field can better prepare doctors to understand the effects of environmental pollutants on our health.The Agents of Change in Environmental Justice podcast is a biweekly podcast featuring the stories and big ideas from past and present fellows, as well as others in the field. You can see all of the past episodes here.Listen below to our discussion with Talayero Schettino and subscribe to the podcast at iTunes or Spotify.Agents of Change in Environmental Justice · Maria Jose Talayero Schettino on using her research to advocate for environmental justice In MexicoTranscriptMaria Jose Talayero Schettino 00:00I don't I really don't think high income countries realize how all their decisions impact developing countries.Brian Bienkowski 00:11Hello and welcome back to the Agents of Change in Environmental Justice podcast, a partnership between Environmental Health News and Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health. I'm your host Brian Bienkowski, editor of Agents of Change, and senior editor at Environmental Health News. Folks, we are so grateful for your support. We've been at this a few years now and we would love to continue to grow. Please share this podcast with your family and friends, colleagues, and subscribe to us on Spotify or iTunes and please leave us a review. Today's guest is Dr. Maria Jose Talayero Schettino, a current fellow and a doctorate pH candidate in the Department of Environmental and Occupational Health at the George Washington University. Maria talks about switching careers from a physician to an environmental health researcher, using her research to advocate for environmental justice in her native Mexico and how the medical field can better prepare doctors to understand the effects of environmental pollutants on our health. Enjoy. All right, I am now joined by Dr. Maria,Jose Talayero Schettino. Maria, how are you doing today?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 01:14I'm doing great. Thanks for having me here. Brian, how are you?Brian Bienkowski 01:18I am doing wonderful. And I'm really excited to hear about all the work that you're doing. But I want to start at the very beginning. Tell me about growing up in Mexico City.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 01:29Oh, yeah, I honestly have very good memories about growing up in Mexico City. But I'm not sure how familiar you are with Mexican culture or if you've ever traveled there, butBrian Bienkowski 01:41almost zeroMaria Jose Talayero Schettino 01:42Mexicans really highly, highly value things like hospitality, generosity, respect for elders, solidarity. And it might sound really funny, but we highly value social connections and gatherings. I mean, it's weird to say that we really value parties, but we do. And that's why our food and culture is so important. So I feel like growing up in Mexico City was just like that: full of culture, tradition, family gatherings. And I feel like I'm very lucky to be able to call myself Mexican.Brian Bienkowski 02:12Is there a certain food or or holiday or gathering? Are there certain ones that kind of stick out in your mind as being particularly poignant?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 02:22I mean, yes, I think so. Particularly, Independence Day. I have very good memories about going to watch the fireworks. Independence Days in September. Most people in America think it's Cinco de Mayo. But that's not it. It's in September. But other holidays that really stick up for me are the other mortos which is in November, and also Posadas, which are held during like, December. So Christmas is very important to us too.Brian Bienkowski 02:54And the only thing I really know about Mexico City, and pardon my American ignorance, is it's it's a massive city, right? I mean, were you in kind of a dense urban area?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 03:04I mean, yeah, it's a huge, huge city. And I feel like there's a lot of people living around Mexico City, I did feel like I lived with my family in one of like, more suburban area, not closer to like, the historical center or anything. But we travel a lot by car. I mean, we have a huge air pollution problem because of that. But I feel like yeah, it's a huge city, and everyone's all around it in. I mean, it's very, very well connected when it comes to streets, we have a lot of traffic, but that's how people go around Mexico City by staying in traffic for really long periods of time.Brian Bienkowski 03:48So how and when did you become interested in health and the environment?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 03:53I mean, this is a great question. And every time I get it, I wish I had that story, "like when I was younger, I used to tell my parents that I wanted to be a doctor since I was a little girl." Unfortunately, that was not me. I wanted to be a singer. I wanted to be an artist. I wanted to be a painter. So that was not me. So I think I ended up in like healthcare and the environment because I really loved science. And don't get me wrong, I really hated physics and math. So because they hated it, I feel like that drew me into chemistry and biology. And I I think I ended up in medical school because of that, because my love for science and honestly, I never knew I was gonna end up doing research and doing a lot of statistics. Even after I ran away from math.Brian Bienkowski 04:42The only class I ever got to see in growing up was chemistry that that that for some reason that subject gave me such fits. And I don't know if it was my teacher, or what but it really bothered me.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 04:54I mean, yeah, it's a really, really hard, hard subject! and I I feel you I feel like I just don't know, I don't know what it was. But chemistry and biology always caught my eye.Brian Bienkowski 05:05eye. And the weird thing is now I, you know, I've spent most of my career writing about chemicals in the environment. So it's, it's strange, I hope I'm not just writing a bunch of incorrect things.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 05:17I guess I guess you've made peace with it. And now you love it.Brian Bienkowski 05:21That's right. So before we get into your your career has been fascinating because you, you started off in healthcare as a physician, and I want to talk about your journey. But first, what is a moment or event that has helped shape your identity?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 05:35Wow, that's a really hard question. I think there are a couple of things that I want to mention that really shaped my identity as I was growing up. And I feel like the first one was really practicing medicine in public hospitals, that really showed me that life is not fair. And that made me want to work on that. And I think the other thing I want to mention that really shaped my identity is immigrating to the United States, even though I emigrated when I was, I think, 26 years old. Even though I'm like a short four-hour flight away from home, I think immigrating made me realize about all the things that I took for granted, and now I really highly value.Brian Bienkowski 06:16Luckily, we're going to talk about both of those things. Because I think that's, it's a really important part of your journey. And starting with this idea of you became a physician in practice in rural communities around Mexico City. So can you tell me about this work, what you learned from this time with patients and why ultimately, you decided to switch careers?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 06:34Of course. So I guess, practicing medicine in rural communities, and even public hospitals, or public health care centers in Mexico, it really does feel like an art. Because you need to learn how to treat disease differently. Sometimes the medicines that you learn on a book that were the best for a specific disease are not available. So you have to work around it. And the same comes for like diagnostic diagnostic tools, you don't have fancy equipment, or even sometimes you don't even have basic equipment to make a diagnosis. So you have to really focus on talking to the patient. And that's the only thing that you often have, and you have to learn how to practice medicine with that, which is the only thing that you have. And I think when it comes to the change that I made from like, a very clinical-practice-based career into like an research and an environmental one is that one of the things that frustrated me that most while I was practicing medicine is that there were and there are still a lot of things that we do not have answers for in patients. When they come to get a diagnosis, they sometimes ask you were themselves like why something happened. And most of the time, we really have to say that we don't know why. I think there's even a medical term for this, which is that something it's adiabatic, which means that we have absolutely no idea what costed and I really hated it. I hated not being able to have answers for my patients. And I mean, I still don't have all the answers. But I think as I moved forward into an environmental health career, I realized that this field of environmental health had a lot of those answers. And that through my medical education, I barely heard of those. So I think that's what made me shift.Brian Bienkowski 08:18So we're going to talk more about your your research and that switch. And, you know, maybe some ideas you have for the medical field to bridge some of these gaps. But I have to ask, did your did family and friends question your decision? I mean, being a physician is a is a career that I think most of us know. I mean, we all know that career. It's familiar to us. It's a pillar in most communities. And I think researcher is a little more esoteric to a lot of folks. So I'm wondering if your family was like, What are you doing?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 08:48Oh, my gosh, yeah, I every single person that went through medical school with me or even my family, or even friends, or even now that I meet people, when I tell them that I went through medical school and that I became a physician. Now I do environmental health, every single person has questioned that. And I feel like sometimes, when like for the Mexican perspective, a lot of people questioned this because they don't really know much about the field, and how important it is. But I don't know like having all these people question your life decision makes it like just harder to move forward and harder to realize if you're in the right path. And I think that was really hard when I first made the decision to switch. But now looking back, I don't think I would do anything differently.Brian Bienkowski 09:38And to keep on this theme of challenges. I want to reflect a bit on your move to the US. You mentioned how important Mexico City and family and gathering was to your, to your upbringing and identity. And I don't know that most folks understand the toll of immigrating even under positive circumstances like yourself. So can you talk about this experience and what people should know about the personal channel changes and sacrifices for immigrants?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 10:02Yeah, honestly, thanks for asking this questions. I think that sometimes the challenges for like immigrating in good, some good circumstances, like I did is invisible to others. But from my experience, I really want to say that immigrating in good circumstances to the US is extremely challenging. There are so many rules and steps that you need to take that often really don't even make sense and can really make your life harder. But I do have to say that I'm really fortunate to be here. And I'm really grateful to the US for the all the all the opportunities that I've had. But moving away from family is so hard. Like you move to a country where you don't have this support system, the culture is extremely different. And you need to talk and communicate using a different language. I don't know if you've watched Modern Family. I really like that show. But there's this episode.Brian Bienkowski 10:54Modern Family? Yeah, gosh, yes. I'm a yes. I'm rewatching it right now. Yes.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 10:59I love it. I love it. But there's this episode, where Sofia Vergara says, "do you know how smart I am in Spanish?" And it's so funny. But it's so relatable. Like, there's so many things that I want to say, but I just cannot find the words.Brian Bienkowski 11:13Well, thank you so much for sharing that. And I want to talk now about the work that you're doing as you've made the switch to research. So you're examining environmental exposures, and birth defects in Mexico. That's one of the things you're working on. So I wanted to talk about talk, you know, if you can explore this link between these exposures and birth defects, why it's concerning, and who is most impacted?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 11:34Of course, yeah. So through my dissertation, I'm on the final stages of my doctoral program, hopefully graduating this August. But through my dissertation, I've been studying birth defects and their relationship that they have with the polluting industry in the country, in Mexico. It has been challenging to do something like this with public databases that the Mexican government has, but I found really interesting things. For example, I've seen that the reporting for genital birth defects in Mexico in the last couple of years has been steadily increasing. I mean, this could be due to so many things –like people know now how to recognize them better or many other things. But when you compare that to other countries, this seems to be happening, too. And it's making us think about the impact endocrine disrupting chemicals are having in communities around industrial areas. I think it is very concerning to see the impact that pollution has in your health even before you were born. Like I don't think people realize that we used to think in a medical field that that placenta was like this major barrier where nothing could go through it. But we've realized that that's not the case. And I really think that we don't have strict enough regulations for most chemicals. But overall, like if you asked me like, What was the most concerning thing that you saw is the lack of data that Mexico has for both health effects and polluting chemicals. I'm always amazed that countries like the US, for example, like researchers in the US say that they are so far behind, but they don't really realize if they're far behind where developing countries are.Brian Bienkowski 13:11You mentioned a term their endocrine disrupting chemicals, which I think a lot of Environmental Health News readership is aware of. But for our listening audience, can you explain what those chemicals are? And kind of the plausible ways that they could possibly be behind some of these birth defects?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 13:26Of course, yeah, sorry, I forgot to explain that! But yeah, endocrine disrupting chemicals are generally what we say are chemicals that are capable of interfering with the way your hormones work. And your hormones are very important since the beginning of life, because hormones are also chemicals, but they mediate a lot of processes in your body. So if there's a chemical there's interrupting those pathways, then you can see problems with your development or the endocrine system diseases, for example, reproductive issues, or diabetes, or thyroid problems. So mostly, those are the things that we're concerned when we get exposed to endocrine disrupting chemicals, which are almost in everything. But one of the major things that we know, gets us exposed to endocrine disrupting chemicals, are plastics.Brian Bienkowski 14:21Soyou mentioned gaps in the research. And you noticed this pretty early on that there were some gaps in environmental health and environmental justice data in Mexico. And I know you're just one researcher, but can you talk about this dearth of research and how you're trying to tackle this?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 14:35So I feel like environmental justice has been overlooked for centuries in both the community scale and the global scale. I really don't think high income countries realize how all their decisions impact developing countries. For example, I remember a few years ago, there was this Super Bowl held in Arizona or one of the border, one of the border states, but I think it was Arizona. And they said that they weren't going to have have a zero-waste Super Bowl because all the plastic generated was going to be recycled. But that plastic was shipped to Mexico, to northern Mexico, where plastic recycling plans are polluting the water and air of Mexican communities. So is one of the of the issues that we see in the global health realm. Like, this is not something that only happens in Mexico, but it happens everywhere. But with things like in the country level, when I first started the process to find something I wanted to do for my dissertation, I remember talking to my chair, about wanting to do something on environmental justice. So I started doing research on what was out there. And unfortunately, I wasn't able to find much. And I think this is related to what I was talking about, that we don't have a lot of data. And there's also something going on in Mexico and you know, other Latin American countries like Colombia, where it's very dangerous to be in environmentalist in those countries. Mexico is one of the deadliest country to be an environmentalist. So advocating for these things can get really challenging.Brian Bienkowski 16:03So can you talk about your efforts, in particular to advance environmental health policy in Mexico, including on lead and criminal behavior? And can you talk a little bit about your involvement with Mundo Químico, boy, I'm probably butchering these words. I'm really smart English, I swear. And what have you learned? And have you had any victories along the way in your in your efforts to advance environmental health policy down there?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 16:28Yeah, so let me talk a little bit about what Mundo Químico is, which translates to chemical world because we live in a chemical world. So this Mundo Químico is like a collaborative of scientists and other professionals in Mexico that got together and are really trying to push programs and policies related to environmental health in the country. Honestly, I feel like I'm very lucky to be part of it. I am the youngest member. And I ended up being there because as I was finishing up my master's program, I always felt like I owed something to my country, and I needed to do something in Mexico. So I did some research and who was working on environmental health in the country. And I found this very big and famous scientist, his name is Dr. Carlos Santos Burdoa. He's US-based. He was at the George Washington University, when I first heard of that of him. So I email him. Honestly, I didn't expect a reply, because like, senior scientists are really busy. But I did get a reply. And I was really surprised. But he told me that he was building this collaborative called Mundo Químico, and he asked me if I wanted to join him. So of course, I said, Yes. So what we've been trying to do, as I was saying, is to push environmental health agenda into the policies and to do some programs to reduce environmental health exposures. And we started with lead exposure, because Mexico has a really big problem with lead. I think we've done different things that I don't think I have enough time to talk about during our podcast. But what I have learned, and I think I have learned a lot of things, but one of the most important ones, is that it is so hard to communicate to the public and with policymakers. And I really did not expect that when I started my career in environmental health. And I think that's how I ended up studying lead exposure and criminal behavior. Because often when you want policymakers to listen to what you have to say, you have to talk to them in their terms, and talk to them in topics that that you feel that they will prioritize. So we know crime is a big thing in Mexico. So what we did is where we viewed all the available evidence to see how lead exposure was related to criminal behavior, we found that there's a link. But we still need research on this. And we need research to understand what the relationship means in the Mexican context. But yeah, I feel like that's how it started because we need to learn to communicate with policymakers. And I really don't want to stop talking about this question without mentioning some of the wins that we had, because I feel like in environmental health, we will always hear a lot about our fatals and not our wins. So we have had some wins, we have been able to produce some programs on lead exposure. And one of them is we were able to partner with WONART, which is an Arts Fund that the government of Mexico has and through their through them, we've been able to push this program to train pottery workers to produce lathe, Clay ceramics, which are a major traditional thing in Mexico and they usually have led in it. But we're pushing this program to produce lead-free clay ceramics and to certify that they're lead free. And even though we still have a lot of work to do on that issue, the start of the program to me is just a great win.Brian Bienkowski 19:54You mentioned two things there that I have a follow up on and you started to get to it a little bit at the end is is you meantioned that lead exposure is a big issue in Mexico. And I'm wondering if you can just kind of give a brief overview of the ceramics and potentially other sources of lead in the environment there. And then second, if you can kind of walk us through why there's this possible link to crime, what does lead do to people that could make them more susceptible to committing crime?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 20:20Of course, yeah. So I'll start with at glaced clay ceramics. So in Mexico, we use traditional pottery for cooking, storing, or even serving food. And one of this traditional pottery is called glaced clay ceramics and the glaze that the ceramics have, it has lead in it. And because it's not produced in ovens, that can reach high enough temperatures, in like close ovens, because it's a very artisanal process, the lead stays there, and it leeches into food. And he usually leeches when you like cook, or store food that's very acidic. And Mexican cuisine is really acidic. So it leaves us a lot of lead. And we have a major problem of lead exposure. Because of that, that's actually the main source of lead exposure in the country, because most of the people in Mexico use it. Like if you go down there, you'll see it in restaurants, you'll see your honestly see it everywhere. And the latest numbers show that children from one to four ages in Mexico, 17% of all children from one to four years of age in Mexico have lead poisoning. So it's a really public health issue, we don't have data to see if older kids have lead, we don't have data on adults. But it's a really big concern, because lead is very toxic, like the WHO says that there is no safe level of exposure to lead because of how toxic it is. And he causes a variety of things. It can increase cardiovascular disease, it can damage the kidneys. But one of the ones, one of the things that we have studied the most is how it damages the nervous system and the brain. And this goes back to the question that you asked about criminal behavior. So we've seen that lead damages the prefrontal cortex of the brain, which is in charge of, of behavior, and, yeah, to put it in, like, easier terms, yeah, it's in charge of behavior and how you react to things. So when it damages the neurons there, it can cause antisocial behavior, and it can cause aggressiveness, and it can cause violent behaviors. So that's how we've seen it has associated with criminal behavior. So in addition to that communication work directly with policymakers and residents, I know you're also active on social media. And I'm wondering how you've leveraged those platforms to try to get the word out on some of these environmental ills. Oh, my gosh, being on social media is so hard. I don't know if you've tried it. But seriously, it takes a lot of effort to create content on social media. But yeah, so I ended up in social media, because going back to this environmental justice issues, Spanish speaking countries, and communities really don't have as much information as English speakers do. And that's something I really noticed while I was scrolling down on every social media platform, so I saw hundreds of videos on how to reduce environmental exposures, but almost none, were in Spanish. So I decided to venture into social media. And honestly, I don't have that many followers, my platform is growing. But one of the things that I've noticed is that many health professionals are starting to follow me because they're interested. And they want to learn more, because some of their patients are asking about these topics. So I feel like it's a great way to do outreach and communication, things when you're in the environmental health field.Brian Bienkowski 24:06I have not tried it. Of course, I had I had social media accounts. It's been more than a decade. I think since I've had one, I don't even have LinkedIn anymore. I am really happy that people like you are on them, because I think it is a counterbalance to the reason that I got off, which is a lot of kind of miss information and hatred. But it is really heartening for me to see folks like yourself and scientists in general and health professionals are able to take their message directly to people as opposed to kind of being mediated through, you know, newspapers or whatever happened back in the day. So I think that's a good thing. And we have noticed though, as a newsroom, a lack of Spanish language environmental content and information and we are trying to trying to combat that with some eh en español coverage. So We have noticed the same thing as you. And there is a real language justice issue in the United States when it comes to environmental information. So I hope people will follow you. We will add a link in this podcast article so people can follow you if you want. Having spent some time now in the environmental health research field, and we were talking earlier about how you started as a physician, how do you think the medical field could better incorporate environmental health information for patients and prepare those physicians?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 25:28I mean, I honestly wish health care workers have better training in environmental health. From my experience, which is going through medical school in Mexico, I really can't speak for other countries. I barely heard about environmental exposures as causes of disease, when I was in medical school, maybe I heard about asbestos or silicosis or occupational exposures, but non an environmental exposures like a social determinants of health, which they are. So I'm currently working actually on a project with some peers on how there is a huge gap in medical and other other healthcare professions school curriculum when it comes to environmental health in Latin America. And it is a sad reality that we barely see courses on environmental health in these curriculums. But I can tell you that I like I can see myself advocating about this for a really long time. And I think we need to get to a point where every single doctor, every single dentist, every single nutritionist, every single nurse knows that this exists, and that we need to know about it and talk to our patients about it.Brian Bienkowski 26:41This is purely anecdotal. But I do feel like I'm seeing more on the climate side of things where physicians are being more active and perhaps more trained in climate change and extreme heat, but less so on –surprisingly– less so on things like chemical exposure, and the things that you've been talking about endocrine disrupting chemicals. So hopefully, hopefully, that changes because I think that would be a real public health win. So, Maria, this has been so much fun hearing about you and your work. And I have to ask you, before we get to some of the fun questions, I have a couple more questions. And one is do you plan on going back to Mexico? Would you want to work there? Or do you think you'll stay in the United States? What do you want to do with this environmental health research training?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 27:25Oh, my gosh, you're putting me on the spot.Brian Bienkowski 27:28I mean, you can have a no comment.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 27:30I know my family's gonna want me to give an answer that maybe it's not the one that they like. But I do feel that the work that I'm doing for Mexico in the United States, is far like, I feel like I have way more opportunities to do something for my country from the United States, than the ones that I see that are my country. And it's a really sad reality, because I would give the world to just go back to my family and my nephews. But if I really want to see a change, I really feel like I have to stay in the United States for at least a couple of years. To improve, like my research techniques to get a better sense of what's out there and what I can do for Mexico. I mean, in the future. I don't know how long from from now, I do see myself going back to Mexico at some point. But right now, I don't think it is an option. And it is a sad reality, not only for me, but for other immigrants that are doing science in the United States, because our countries lack opportunities.Brian Bienkowski 28:39And Maria, before we get to the fun stuff, what are you optimistic about?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 28:44Oh, that's a really important question! I feel like we don't hear about optimism sometimes in the environmental field, like there are so it's filled with bad news sometimes. But I feel like I'm optimistic about hearing more people are learning about environmental exposure. So how they can affect their health, because honestly, sometimes social movements can move policies faster. So we really need that. I'm optimistic about how younger generations are thinking more about the environment now. And they're joining this fight. There are so many things I'm optimistic about. And I'm glad you brought this up. Because again, I don't think that this field is full of good news. So we need to, to have these victories and these things that we're optimistic about really present in our day to day because he can get overwhelming at times.Brian Bienkowski 29:37I think the hard thing in my profession and maybe this is true in science in science communication as well, is whenever we try to talk about good news, it often feels like we're perhaps greenwashing or perhaps we're overlooking, you know, renewable energy is a great example. You know, solar energy and wind energy are less polluting, however now we have to go get those chemicals to make those panels in the ground and community. You know, so there's always there's other problems and we don't want to overlook those. But I totally agree with you that we need to be better as a, as a country in general about celebrating environmental wins, so people just don't get so down about it.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 30:17Yeah, cuz I mean, when I talk to people about toxic exposures, I usually get the same reaction, like, everything's toxic, I'm gonna die from something. So I might as well just stop thinking about this. And I don't think that's a great approach. So, I mean, that should go back to our communication efforts, like, what are we saying, what are we doing? And how can we make this better? So our message gets out there, and it's not as overwhelming as it is currently.Brian Bienkowski 30:43100% totally agree with you. Well, Maria, thank you so much for your time. I'm just so I'm so happy to have met you and have you in this program. I'm just really excited about the work you're doing. So before I get you out of here, I have a few rapid fire questions where you can just answer with a one word or a phrase, if I have a whole day off, I am likely.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 31:05Oh my gosh, I'm probably hitting the craft store to find a new craft to doBrian Bienkowski 31:09What what type of crafting do you like do?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 31:12anything, like anything like it, maybe it's knitting, maybe it's stitching, maybe it's painting, whatever, like, whatever is new, I'm doing it.Brian Bienkowski 31:22So my wife and I, we live in the Upper Peninsula. And so we have very long winters. And I find myself this time of year. And I hesitate to even say this pining for winter, because it is such a great time to be quiet. And I play I'm playing music and my wife does be beadwork and stuff like that. Or we do some paintings together. And it's all crafty, and it's cozy and quiet. And then in the summer, I find that I really miss those. I really missed those times. So I need to find a way to do more crafty things, when it's nice outside. Yeah,Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 31:54I can relate to that. 100% I feel like it's a great therapy to do craftBrian Bienkowski 31:58100%. Well, I just had a guest on who was the guest, I'm forgetting now. But I had a guest on we were talking crafts not too long ago, I'll have to dig that out. Because I think it's for folks like yourself who are really busy doing this kind of work. It's good to have that other side of your creative brain get used every now and then. So the best gift I've ever received isMaria Jose Talayero Schettino 32:22I'm gonna see my family.Brian Bienkowski 32:24And if I could immediately gain one talent or ability it would beMaria Jose Talayero Schettino 32:31I know, to be able to get grants for research without being rejected.Brian Bienkowski 32:37Not flight or invisibility, just just grants! this one good for research. keeping it simple. I like that. And you do not have to. You can talk more than one word or a phrase here. What is the last book you read for fun?Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 32:53Oh, this is a good one. So lately because I've been working on my dissertation. I feel like I've been reading a lot of science stuff. But I feel like the last book that I read it was, I feel it was last year. And it's a book by a Mexican Indigenous woman, well, Ilfrosina Cruz who is now a representative in the Mexican government. And it's a great book. I'm not gonna spoil it for everyone. But she talks about her life as an Indigenous girl and how she wanted something different. And she wanted to create opportunities. And she moved on to be a representative and changing the laws in Mexico. So it's a really inspiring book, and I highly recommend it, it is called "Los Sueños de la niña de la montaña," which translates to "The Dreams from the girl up the mountain. I don't know if it's available in English yet, but I know it's in Spanish and I really highly recommended.Brian Bienkowski 33:46Excellent. Well, Maria, thank you so much for your time today. Thank you for being part of this program, and we'll have you back soon.Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 33:51Thank you. Thank you so much for having me. It was a great talk.Brian Bienkowski 33:59That's all for this week. folks. I hope you enjoyed my conversation with Maria. If you enjoyed this podcast, visit agentsofchangeinej.org. And while you're there, click the donate button to support us or sign up for our free monthly newsletter. You can also find us on X, Instagram and follow us on Spotify or iTunes and never miss an episode give us a rating. This agency chain podcast was recorded written produced and edited by me with outreaching scheduling and support from the rest of the team Dr. Ami Zota Dr. Yoshiro Cornelis Van Horn Dr. Veena singlet, Dr. Max on Dr. Laura Edwards, summer Ahmad and Maria Paula Rubiano. Our music is now sung by Paddington Bear. Thanks for joining us. We hope to keep these important conversations on diversity in science and health. Go. Have a great week folks.



Dr. Maria Jose Talayero Schettino joins the Agents of Change in Environmental Justice podcast to discuss why she switched careers from physician to environmental health researcher, and how she’s using this new training to advocate for environmental justice in Mexico.


Talayero Schettino, a current Agents of Change fellow and a DrPH candidate in the Department of Environmental and Occupational Health at The George Washington University, also talks about the challenges of immigrating to the U.S. and how the medical field can better prepare doctors to understand the effects of environmental pollutants on our health.

The Agents of Change in Environmental Justice podcast is a biweekly podcast featuring the stories and big ideas from past and present fellows, as well as others in the field. You can see all of the past episodes here.

Listen below to our discussion with Talayero Schettino and subscribe to the podcast at iTunes or Spotify.


Agents of Change in Environmental Justice · Maria Jose Talayero Schettino on using her research to advocate for environmental justice In Mexico

Transcript


Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 00:00

I don't I really don't think high income countries realize how all their decisions impact developing countries.

Brian Bienkowski 00:11

Hello and welcome back to the Agents of Change in Environmental Justice podcast, a partnership between Environmental Health News and Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health. I'm your host Brian Bienkowski, editor of Agents of Change, and senior editor at Environmental Health News. Folks, we are so grateful for your support. We've been at this a few years now and we would love to continue to grow. Please share this podcast with your family and friends, colleagues, and subscribe to us on Spotify or iTunes and please leave us a review. Today's guest is Dr. Maria Jose Talayero Schettino, a current fellow and a doctorate pH candidate in the Department of Environmental and Occupational Health at the George Washington University. Maria talks about switching careers from a physician to an environmental health researcher, using her research to advocate for environmental justice in her native Mexico and how the medical field can better prepare doctors to understand the effects of environmental pollutants on our health. Enjoy. All right, I am now joined by Dr. Maria,Jose Talayero Schettino. Maria, how are you doing today?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 01:14

I'm doing great. Thanks for having me here. Brian, how are you?

Brian Bienkowski 01:18

I am doing wonderful. And I'm really excited to hear about all the work that you're doing. But I want to start at the very beginning. Tell me about growing up in Mexico City.

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 01:29

Oh, yeah, I honestly have very good memories about growing up in Mexico City. But I'm not sure how familiar you are with Mexican culture or if you've ever traveled there, but

Brian Bienkowski 01:41

almost zero

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 01:42

Mexicans really highly, highly value things like hospitality, generosity, respect for elders, solidarity. And it might sound really funny, but we highly value social connections and gatherings. I mean, it's weird to say that we really value parties, but we do. And that's why our food and culture is so important. So I feel like growing up in Mexico City was just like that: full of culture, tradition, family gatherings. And I feel like I'm very lucky to be able to call myself Mexican.

Brian Bienkowski 02:12

Is there a certain food or or holiday or gathering? Are there certain ones that kind of stick out in your mind as being particularly poignant?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 02:22

I mean, yes, I think so. Particularly, Independence Day. I have very good memories about going to watch the fireworks. Independence Days in September. Most people in America think it's Cinco de Mayo. But that's not it. It's in September. But other holidays that really stick up for me are the other mortos which is in November, and also Posadas, which are held during like, December. So Christmas is very important to us too.

Brian Bienkowski 02:54

And the only thing I really know about Mexico City, and pardon my American ignorance, is it's it's a massive city, right? I mean, were you in kind of a dense urban area?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 03:04

I mean, yeah, it's a huge, huge city. And I feel like there's a lot of people living around Mexico City, I did feel like I lived with my family in one of like, more suburban area, not closer to like, the historical center or anything. But we travel a lot by car. I mean, we have a huge air pollution problem because of that. But I feel like yeah, it's a huge city, and everyone's all around it in. I mean, it's very, very well connected when it comes to streets, we have a lot of traffic, but that's how people go around Mexico City by staying in traffic for really long periods of time.

Brian Bienkowski 03:48

So how and when did you become interested in health and the environment?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 03:53

I mean, this is a great question. And every time I get it, I wish I had that story, "like when I was younger, I used to tell my parents that I wanted to be a doctor since I was a little girl." Unfortunately, that was not me. I wanted to be a singer. I wanted to be an artist. I wanted to be a painter. So that was not me. So I think I ended up in like healthcare and the environment because I really loved science. And don't get me wrong, I really hated physics and math. So because they hated it, I feel like that drew me into chemistry and biology. And I I think I ended up in medical school because of that, because my love for science and honestly, I never knew I was gonna end up doing research and doing a lot of statistics. Even after I ran away from math.

Brian Bienkowski 04:42

The only class I ever got to see in growing up was chemistry that that that for some reason that subject gave me such fits. And I don't know if it was my teacher, or what but it really bothered me.

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 04:54

I mean, yeah, it's a really, really hard, hard subject! and I I feel you I feel like I just don't know, I don't know what it was. But chemistry and biology always caught my eye.

Brian Bienkowski 05:05

eye. And the weird thing is now I, you know, I've spent most of my career writing about chemicals in the environment. So it's, it's strange, I hope I'm not just writing a bunch of incorrect things.

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 05:17

I guess I guess you've made peace with it. And now you love it.

Brian Bienkowski 05:21

That's right. So before we get into your your career has been fascinating because you, you started off in healthcare as a physician, and I want to talk about your journey. But first, what is a moment or event that has helped shape your identity?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 05:35

Wow, that's a really hard question. I think there are a couple of things that I want to mention that really shaped my identity as I was growing up. And I feel like the first one was really practicing medicine in public hospitals, that really showed me that life is not fair. And that made me want to work on that. And I think the other thing I want to mention that really shaped my identity is immigrating to the United States, even though I emigrated when I was, I think, 26 years old. Even though I'm like a short four-hour flight away from home, I think immigrating made me realize about all the things that I took for granted, and now I really highly value.

Brian Bienkowski 06:16

Luckily, we're going to talk about both of those things. Because I think that's, it's a really important part of your journey. And starting with this idea of you became a physician in practice in rural communities around Mexico City. So can you tell me about this work, what you learned from this time with patients and why ultimately, you decided to switch careers?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 06:34

Of course. So I guess, practicing medicine in rural communities, and even public hospitals, or public health care centers in Mexico, it really does feel like an art. Because you need to learn how to treat disease differently. Sometimes the medicines that you learn on a book that were the best for a specific disease are not available. So you have to work around it. And the same comes for like diagnostic diagnostic tools, you don't have fancy equipment, or even sometimes you don't even have basic equipment to make a diagnosis. So you have to really focus on talking to the patient. And that's the only thing that you often have, and you have to learn how to practice medicine with that, which is the only thing that you have. And I think when it comes to the change that I made from like, a very clinical-practice-based career into like an research and an environmental one is that one of the things that frustrated me that most while I was practicing medicine is that there were and there are still a lot of things that we do not have answers for in patients. When they come to get a diagnosis, they sometimes ask you were themselves like why something happened. And most of the time, we really have to say that we don't know why. I think there's even a medical term for this, which is that something it's adiabatic, which means that we have absolutely no idea what costed and I really hated it. I hated not being able to have answers for my patients. And I mean, I still don't have all the answers. But I think as I moved forward into an environmental health career, I realized that this field of environmental health had a lot of those answers. And that through my medical education, I barely heard of those. So I think that's what made me shift.

Brian Bienkowski 08:18

So we're going to talk more about your your research and that switch. And, you know, maybe some ideas you have for the medical field to bridge some of these gaps. But I have to ask, did your did family and friends question your decision? I mean, being a physician is a is a career that I think most of us know. I mean, we all know that career. It's familiar to us. It's a pillar in most communities. And I think researcher is a little more esoteric to a lot of folks. So I'm wondering if your family was like, What are you doing?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 08:48

Oh, my gosh, yeah, I every single person that went through medical school with me or even my family, or even friends, or even now that I meet people, when I tell them that I went through medical school and that I became a physician. Now I do environmental health, every single person has questioned that. And I feel like sometimes, when like for the Mexican perspective, a lot of people questioned this because they don't really know much about the field, and how important it is. But I don't know like having all these people question your life decision makes it like just harder to move forward and harder to realize if you're in the right path. And I think that was really hard when I first made the decision to switch. But now looking back, I don't think I would do anything differently.

Brian Bienkowski 09:38

And to keep on this theme of challenges. I want to reflect a bit on your move to the US. You mentioned how important Mexico City and family and gathering was to your, to your upbringing and identity. And I don't know that most folks understand the toll of immigrating even under positive circumstances like yourself. So can you talk about this experience and what people should know about the personal channel changes and sacrifices for immigrants?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 10:02

Yeah, honestly, thanks for asking this questions. I think that sometimes the challenges for like immigrating in good, some good circumstances, like I did is invisible to others. But from my experience, I really want to say that immigrating in good circumstances to the US is extremely challenging. There are so many rules and steps that you need to take that often really don't even make sense and can really make your life harder. But I do have to say that I'm really fortunate to be here. And I'm really grateful to the US for the all the all the opportunities that I've had. But moving away from family is so hard. Like you move to a country where you don't have this support system, the culture is extremely different. And you need to talk and communicate using a different language. I don't know if you've watched Modern Family. I really like that show. But there's this episode.

Brian Bienkowski 10:54

Modern Family? Yeah, gosh, yes. I'm a yes. I'm rewatching it right now. Yes.

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 10:59

I love it. I love it. But there's this episode, where Sofia Vergara says, "do you know how smart I am in Spanish?" And it's so funny. But it's so relatable. Like, there's so many things that I want to say, but I just cannot find the words.

Brian Bienkowski 11:13

Well, thank you so much for sharing that. And I want to talk now about the work that you're doing as you've made the switch to research. So you're examining environmental exposures, and birth defects in Mexico. That's one of the things you're working on. So I wanted to talk about talk, you know, if you can explore this link between these exposures and birth defects, why it's concerning, and who is most impacted?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 11:34

Of course, yeah. So through my dissertation, I'm on the final stages of my doctoral program, hopefully graduating this August. But through my dissertation, I've been studying birth defects and their relationship that they have with the polluting industry in the country, in Mexico. It has been challenging to do something like this with public databases that the Mexican government has, but I found really interesting things. For example, I've seen that the reporting for genital birth defects in Mexico in the last couple of years has been steadily increasing. I mean, this could be due to so many things –like people know now how to recognize them better or many other things. But when you compare that to other countries, this seems to be happening, too. And it's making us think about the impact endocrine disrupting chemicals are having in communities around industrial areas. I think it is very concerning to see the impact that pollution has in your health even before you were born. Like I don't think people realize that we used to think in a medical field that that placenta was like this major barrier where nothing could go through it. But we've realized that that's not the case. And I really think that we don't have strict enough regulations for most chemicals. But overall, like if you asked me like, What was the most concerning thing that you saw is the lack of data that Mexico has for both health effects and polluting chemicals. I'm always amazed that countries like the US, for example, like researchers in the US say that they are so far behind, but they don't really realize if they're far behind where developing countries are.

Brian Bienkowski 13:11

You mentioned a term their endocrine disrupting chemicals, which I think a lot of Environmental Health News readership is aware of. But for our listening audience, can you explain what those chemicals are? And kind of the plausible ways that they could possibly be behind some of these birth defects?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 13:26

Of course, yeah, sorry, I forgot to explain that! But yeah, endocrine disrupting chemicals are generally what we say are chemicals that are capable of interfering with the way your hormones work. And your hormones are very important since the beginning of life, because hormones are also chemicals, but they mediate a lot of processes in your body. So if there's a chemical there's interrupting those pathways, then you can see problems with your development or the endocrine system diseases, for example, reproductive issues, or diabetes, or thyroid problems. So mostly, those are the things that we're concerned when we get exposed to endocrine disrupting chemicals, which are almost in everything. But one of the major things that we know, gets us exposed to endocrine disrupting chemicals, are plastics.

Brian Bienkowski 14:21

Soyou mentioned gaps in the research. And you noticed this pretty early on that there were some gaps in environmental health and environmental justice data in Mexico. And I know you're just one researcher, but can you talk about this dearth of research and how you're trying to tackle this?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 14:35

So I feel like environmental justice has been overlooked for centuries in both the community scale and the global scale. I really don't think high income countries realize how all their decisions impact developing countries. For example, I remember a few years ago, there was this Super Bowl held in Arizona or one of the border, one of the border states, but I think it was Arizona. And they said that they weren't going to have have a zero-waste Super Bowl because all the plastic generated was going to be recycled. But that plastic was shipped to Mexico, to northern Mexico, where plastic recycling plans are polluting the water and air of Mexican communities. So is one of the of the issues that we see in the global health realm. Like, this is not something that only happens in Mexico, but it happens everywhere. But with things like in the country level, when I first started the process to find something I wanted to do for my dissertation, I remember talking to my chair, about wanting to do something on environmental justice. So I started doing research on what was out there. And unfortunately, I wasn't able to find much. And I think this is related to what I was talking about, that we don't have a lot of data. And there's also something going on in Mexico and you know, other Latin American countries like Colombia, where it's very dangerous to be in environmentalist in those countries. Mexico is one of the deadliest country to be an environmentalist. So advocating for these things can get really challenging.

Brian Bienkowski 16:03

So can you talk about your efforts, in particular to advance environmental health policy in Mexico, including on lead and criminal behavior? And can you talk a little bit about your involvement with Mundo Químico, boy, I'm probably butchering these words. I'm really smart English, I swear. And what have you learned? And have you had any victories along the way in your in your efforts to advance environmental health policy down there?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 16:28

Yeah, so let me talk a little bit about what Mundo Químico is, which translates to chemical world because we live in a chemical world. So this Mundo Químico is like a collaborative of scientists and other professionals in Mexico that got together and are really trying to push programs and policies related to environmental health in the country. Honestly, I feel like I'm very lucky to be part of it. I am the youngest member. And I ended up being there because as I was finishing up my master's program, I always felt like I owed something to my country, and I needed to do something in Mexico. So I did some research and who was working on environmental health in the country. And I found this very big and famous scientist, his name is Dr. Carlos Santos Burdoa. He's US-based. He was at the George Washington University, when I first heard of that of him. So I email him. Honestly, I didn't expect a reply, because like, senior scientists are really busy. But I did get a reply. And I was really surprised. But he told me that he was building this collaborative called Mundo Químico, and he asked me if I wanted to join him. So of course, I said, Yes. So what we've been trying to do, as I was saying, is to push environmental health agenda into the policies and to do some programs to reduce environmental health exposures. And we started with lead exposure, because Mexico has a really big problem with lead. I think we've done different things that I don't think I have enough time to talk about during our podcast. But what I have learned, and I think I have learned a lot of things, but one of the most important ones, is that it is so hard to communicate to the public and with policymakers. And I really did not expect that when I started my career in environmental health. And I think that's how I ended up studying lead exposure and criminal behavior. Because often when you want policymakers to listen to what you have to say, you have to talk to them in their terms, and talk to them in topics that that you feel that they will prioritize. So we know crime is a big thing in Mexico. So what we did is where we viewed all the available evidence to see how lead exposure was related to criminal behavior, we found that there's a link. But we still need research on this. And we need research to understand what the relationship means in the Mexican context. But yeah, I feel like that's how it started because we need to learn to communicate with policymakers. And I really don't want to stop talking about this question without mentioning some of the wins that we had, because I feel like in environmental health, we will always hear a lot about our fatals and not our wins. So we have had some wins, we have been able to produce some programs on lead exposure. And one of them is we were able to partner with WONART, which is an Arts Fund that the government of Mexico has and through their through them, we've been able to push this program to train pottery workers to produce lathe, Clay ceramics, which are a major traditional thing in Mexico and they usually have led in it. But we're pushing this program to produce lead-free clay ceramics and to certify that they're lead free. And even though we still have a lot of work to do on that issue, the start of the program to me is just a great win.

Brian Bienkowski 19:54

You mentioned two things there that I have a follow up on and you started to get to it a little bit at the end is is you meantioned that lead exposure is a big issue in Mexico. And I'm wondering if you can just kind of give a brief overview of the ceramics and potentially other sources of lead in the environment there. And then second, if you can kind of walk us through why there's this possible link to crime, what does lead do to people that could make them more susceptible to committing crime?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 20:20

Of course, yeah. So I'll start with at glaced clay ceramics. So in Mexico, we use traditional pottery for cooking, storing, or even serving food. And one of this traditional pottery is called glaced clay ceramics and the glaze that the ceramics have, it has lead in it. And because it's not produced in ovens, that can reach high enough temperatures, in like close ovens, because it's a very artisanal process, the lead stays there, and it leeches into food. And he usually leeches when you like cook, or store food that's very acidic. And Mexican cuisine is really acidic. So it leaves us a lot of lead. And we have a major problem of lead exposure. Because of that, that's actually the main source of lead exposure in the country, because most of the people in Mexico use it. Like if you go down there, you'll see it in restaurants, you'll see your honestly see it everywhere. And the latest numbers show that children from one to four ages in Mexico, 17% of all children from one to four years of age in Mexico have lead poisoning. So it's a really public health issue, we don't have data to see if older kids have lead, we don't have data on adults. But it's a really big concern, because lead is very toxic, like the WHO says that there is no safe level of exposure to lead because of how toxic it is. And he causes a variety of things. It can increase cardiovascular disease, it can damage the kidneys. But one of the ones, one of the things that we have studied the most is how it damages the nervous system and the brain. And this goes back to the question that you asked about criminal behavior. So we've seen that lead damages the prefrontal cortex of the brain, which is in charge of, of behavior, and, yeah, to put it in, like, easier terms, yeah, it's in charge of behavior and how you react to things. So when it damages the neurons there, it can cause antisocial behavior, and it can cause aggressiveness, and it can cause violent behaviors. So that's how we've seen it has associated with criminal behavior. So in addition to that communication work directly with policymakers and residents, I know you're also active on social media. And I'm wondering how you've leveraged those platforms to try to get the word out on some of these environmental ills. Oh, my gosh, being on social media is so hard. I don't know if you've tried it. But seriously, it takes a lot of effort to create content on social media. But yeah, so I ended up in social media, because going back to this environmental justice issues, Spanish speaking countries, and communities really don't have as much information as English speakers do. And that's something I really noticed while I was scrolling down on every social media platform, so I saw hundreds of videos on how to reduce environmental exposures, but almost none, were in Spanish. So I decided to venture into social media. And honestly, I don't have that many followers, my platform is growing. But one of the things that I've noticed is that many health professionals are starting to follow me because they're interested. And they want to learn more, because some of their patients are asking about these topics. So I feel like it's a great way to do outreach and communication, things when you're in the environmental health field.

Brian Bienkowski 24:06

I have not tried it. Of course, I had I had social media accounts. It's been more than a decade. I think since I've had one, I don't even have LinkedIn anymore. I am really happy that people like you are on them, because I think it is a counterbalance to the reason that I got off, which is a lot of kind of miss information and hatred. But it is really heartening for me to see folks like yourself and scientists in general and health professionals are able to take their message directly to people as opposed to kind of being mediated through, you know, newspapers or whatever happened back in the day. So I think that's a good thing. And we have noticed though, as a newsroom, a lack of Spanish language environmental content and information and we are trying to trying to combat that with some eh en español coverage. So We have noticed the same thing as you. And there is a real language justice issue in the United States when it comes to environmental information. So I hope people will follow you. We will add a link in this podcast article so people can follow you if you want. Having spent some time now in the environmental health research field, and we were talking earlier about how you started as a physician, how do you think the medical field could better incorporate environmental health information for patients and prepare those physicians?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 25:28

I mean, I honestly wish health care workers have better training in environmental health. From my experience, which is going through medical school in Mexico, I really can't speak for other countries. I barely heard about environmental exposures as causes of disease, when I was in medical school, maybe I heard about asbestos or silicosis or occupational exposures, but non an environmental exposures like a social determinants of health, which they are. So I'm currently working actually on a project with some peers on how there is a huge gap in medical and other other healthcare professions school curriculum when it comes to environmental health in Latin America. And it is a sad reality that we barely see courses on environmental health in these curriculums. But I can tell you that I like I can see myself advocating about this for a really long time. And I think we need to get to a point where every single doctor, every single dentist, every single nutritionist, every single nurse knows that this exists, and that we need to know about it and talk to our patients about it.

Brian Bienkowski 26:41

This is purely anecdotal. But I do feel like I'm seeing more on the climate side of things where physicians are being more active and perhaps more trained in climate change and extreme heat, but less so on –surprisingly– less so on things like chemical exposure, and the things that you've been talking about endocrine disrupting chemicals. So hopefully, hopefully, that changes because I think that would be a real public health win. So, Maria, this has been so much fun hearing about you and your work. And I have to ask you, before we get to some of the fun questions, I have a couple more questions. And one is do you plan on going back to Mexico? Would you want to work there? Or do you think you'll stay in the United States? What do you want to do with this environmental health research training?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 27:25

Oh, my gosh, you're putting me on the spot.

Brian Bienkowski 27:28

I mean, you can have a no comment.

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 27:30

I know my family's gonna want me to give an answer that maybe it's not the one that they like. But I do feel that the work that I'm doing for Mexico in the United States, is far like, I feel like I have way more opportunities to do something for my country from the United States, than the ones that I see that are my country. And it's a really sad reality, because I would give the world to just go back to my family and my nephews. But if I really want to see a change, I really feel like I have to stay in the United States for at least a couple of years. To improve, like my research techniques to get a better sense of what's out there and what I can do for Mexico. I mean, in the future. I don't know how long from from now, I do see myself going back to Mexico at some point. But right now, I don't think it is an option. And it is a sad reality, not only for me, but for other immigrants that are doing science in the United States, because our countries lack opportunities.

Brian Bienkowski 28:39

And Maria, before we get to the fun stuff, what are you optimistic about?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 28:44

Oh, that's a really important question! I feel like we don't hear about optimism sometimes in the environmental field, like there are so it's filled with bad news sometimes. But I feel like I'm optimistic about hearing more people are learning about environmental exposure. So how they can affect their health, because honestly, sometimes social movements can move policies faster. So we really need that. I'm optimistic about how younger generations are thinking more about the environment now. And they're joining this fight. There are so many things I'm optimistic about. And I'm glad you brought this up. Because again, I don't think that this field is full of good news. So we need to, to have these victories and these things that we're optimistic about really present in our day to day because he can get overwhelming at times.

Brian Bienkowski 29:37

I think the hard thing in my profession and maybe this is true in science in science communication as well, is whenever we try to talk about good news, it often feels like we're perhaps greenwashing or perhaps we're overlooking, you know, renewable energy is a great example. You know, solar energy and wind energy are less polluting, however now we have to go get those chemicals to make those panels in the ground and community. You know, so there's always there's other problems and we don't want to overlook those. But I totally agree with you that we need to be better as a, as a country in general about celebrating environmental wins, so people just don't get so down about it.

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 30:17

Yeah, cuz I mean, when I talk to people about toxic exposures, I usually get the same reaction, like, everything's toxic, I'm gonna die from something. So I might as well just stop thinking about this. And I don't think that's a great approach. So, I mean, that should go back to our communication efforts, like, what are we saying, what are we doing? And how can we make this better? So our message gets out there, and it's not as overwhelming as it is currently.

Brian Bienkowski 30:43

100% totally agree with you. Well, Maria, thank you so much for your time. I'm just so I'm so happy to have met you and have you in this program. I'm just really excited about the work you're doing. So before I get you out of here, I have a few rapid fire questions where you can just answer with a one word or a phrase, if I have a whole day off, I am likely.

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 31:05

Oh my gosh, I'm probably hitting the craft store to find a new craft to do

Brian Bienkowski 31:09

What what type of crafting do you like do?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 31:12

anything, like anything like it, maybe it's knitting, maybe it's stitching, maybe it's painting, whatever, like, whatever is new, I'm doing it.

Brian Bienkowski 31:22

So my wife and I, we live in the Upper Peninsula. And so we have very long winters. And I find myself this time of year. And I hesitate to even say this pining for winter, because it is such a great time to be quiet. And I play I'm playing music and my wife does be beadwork and stuff like that. Or we do some paintings together. And it's all crafty, and it's cozy and quiet. And then in the summer, I find that I really miss those. I really missed those times. So I need to find a way to do more crafty things, when it's nice outside. Yeah,

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 31:54

I can relate to that. 100% I feel like it's a great therapy to do craft

Brian Bienkowski 31:58

100%. Well, I just had a guest on who was the guest, I'm forgetting now. But I had a guest on we were talking crafts not too long ago, I'll have to dig that out. Because I think it's for folks like yourself who are really busy doing this kind of work. It's good to have that other side of your creative brain get used every now and then. So the best gift I've ever received is

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 32:22

I'm gonna see my family.

Brian Bienkowski 32:24

And if I could immediately gain one talent or ability it would be

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 32:31

I know, to be able to get grants for research without being rejected.

Brian Bienkowski 32:37

Not flight or invisibility, just just grants! this one good for research. keeping it simple. I like that. And you do not have to. You can talk more than one word or a phrase here. What is the last book you read for fun?

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 32:53

Oh, this is a good one. So lately because I've been working on my dissertation. I feel like I've been reading a lot of science stuff. But I feel like the last book that I read it was, I feel it was last year. And it's a book by a Mexican Indigenous woman, well, Ilfrosina Cruz who is now a representative in the Mexican government. And it's a great book. I'm not gonna spoil it for everyone. But she talks about her life as an Indigenous girl and how she wanted something different. And she wanted to create opportunities. And she moved on to be a representative and changing the laws in Mexico. So it's a really inspiring book, and I highly recommend it, it is called "Los Sueños de la niña de la montaña," which translates to "The Dreams from the girl up the mountain. I don't know if it's available in English yet, but I know it's in Spanish and I really highly recommended.

Brian Bienkowski 33:46

Excellent. Well, Maria, thank you so much for your time today. Thank you for being part of this program, and we'll have you back soon.

Maria Jose Talayero Schettino 33:51

Thank you. Thank you so much for having me. It was a great talk.

Brian Bienkowski 33:59

That's all for this week. folks. I hope you enjoyed my conversation with Maria. If you enjoyed this podcast, visit agentsofchangeinej.org. And while you're there, click the donate button to support us or sign up for our free monthly newsletter. You can also find us on X, Instagram and follow us on Spotify or iTunes and never miss an episode give us a rating. This agency chain podcast was recorded written produced and edited by me with outreaching scheduling and support from the rest of the team Dr. Ami Zota Dr. Yoshiro Cornelis Van Horn Dr. Veena singlet, Dr. Max on Dr. Laura Edwards, summer Ahmad and Maria Paula Rubiano. Our music is now sung by Paddington Bear. Thanks for joining us. We hope to keep these important conversations on diversity in science and health. Go. Have a great week folks.

Read the full story here.
Photos courtesy of

Forever Chemicals' Common in Cosmetics, but FDA Says Safety Data Are Scant

By Deanna Neff HealthDay ReporterSATURDAY, Jan. 3, 2026 (HealthDay News) — Federal regulators have released a mandated report regarding the...

By Deanna Neff HealthDay ReporterSATURDAY, Jan. 3, 2026 (HealthDay News) — Federal regulators have released a mandated report regarding the presence of "forever chemicals" in makeup and skincare products. Forever chemicals — known as perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances or PFAS — are manmade chemicals that don't break down and have built up in people’s bodies and the environment. They are sometimes added to beauty products intentionally, and sometimes they are contaminants. While the findings confirm that PFAS are widely used in the beauty industry, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) admitted it lacks enough scientific evidence to determine if they are truly safe for consumers.The new report reveals that 51 forever chemicals — are used in 1,744 cosmetic formulations. These synthetic chemicals are favored by manufacturers because they make products waterproof, increase their durability and improve texture.FDA scientists focused their review on the 25 most frequently used PFAS, which account for roughly 96% of these chemicals found in beauty products. The results were largely unclear. While five were deemed to have low safety concerns, one was flagged for potential health risks, and safety of the rest could not be confirmed.FDA Commissioner Dr. Marty Makary expressed concern over the difficulty in accessing private research. “Our scientists found that toxicological data for most PFAS are incomplete or unavailable, leaving significant uncertainty about consumer safety,” Makary said in a news release, adding that “this lack of reliable data demands further research.”Despite growing concerns about their potential toxicity, no federal laws specifically ban their use in cosmetics.The FDA report focuses on chemicals that are added to products on purpose, rather than those that might show up as accidental contaminants. Moving forward, FDA plans to work closely with the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to update and strengthen recommendations on PFAS across the retail and food supply chain, Makary said. The agency has vowed to devote more resources to monitoring these chemicals and will take enforcement action if specific products are proven to be dangerous.The U.S. Food and Drug Administration provides updates and consumer guidance on the use of PFAS in cosmetics.SOURCE: U.S. Food and Drug Administration, news release, Dec. 29, 2025Copyright © 2026 HealthDay. All rights reserved.

Lawsuit claims worker suffered ‘chemical exposure’ from sulfuric acid leak in Houston Ship Channel

According to the lawsuit filed Wednesday, Jeffery Lee Lawson claims he suffered from “burning lungs, shortness of breath, pain in his throat, nausea, dizziness and skin irritation” as a result of the chemical leak. 

Court According to the lawsuit filed Wednesday, Jeffery Lee Lawson claims he suffered from “burning lungs, shortness of breath, pain in his throat, nausea, dizziness and skin irritation” as a result of the chemical leak.  Kyle McClenagan | Posted on January 2, 2026, 10:13 AM (Last Updated: January 2, 2026, 11:01 AM) Gail Delaughter/Houston Public MediaPictured is an aerial view of activity on the Houston Ship Channel in May 2019.A worker who was on a tanker ship in the Houston Ship Channel during a sulfuric acid leak last week has filed a lawsuit accusing the owner of the facility where the leak occurred of being "grossly negligent." According to the lawsuit filed Wednesday, Jeffery Lee Lawson claims he suffered from "burning lungs, shortness of breath, pain in his throat, nausea, dizziness and skin irritation" as a result of the chemical leak. The leak occurred in the early morning of Saturday, Dec. 27, after an elevated walkway collapsed and ruptured a pipeline at the BWC Terminals facility in Channelview, east of Houston. According to Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo, approximately 1 million gallons of sulfuric acid were released as a result. Sign up for the Hello, Houston! daily newsletter to get local reports like this delivered directly to your inbox. At the time of the leak, Lawson was working as a tankerman on a ship about 500 feet from the BWC Terminals facility, according to the lawsuit. "At approximately 2 a.m., Mr. Lawson heard a loud crash and subsequently saw a large gas cloud being released from the terminal," the lawsuit claims. "No alarms, warnings, or notifications were provided by Defendants. Shortly thereafter, Mr. Lawson was enveloped by the toxic substance and began to suffer from immediate physical injuries." ProvidedA photo of the apparent sulfuric acid leak at the BWC Terminals facility near the Houston Ship Channel included in a lawsuit against the company.The lawsuit names BWC Terminals LLC and BWC Texas Terminals LLC as the defendants and accuses the company of over a dozen alleged "grossly negligent" acts, including several alleged safety failures and Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSAH) violations. Sulfuric acid is a colorless, oily liquid that is highly corrosive. Exposure to it can cause skin burns and irritate the eyes, lungs and digestive system, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. It can also be fatal. In a statement to Houston Public Media on Friday, a BWC Terminals spokesperson declined to comment and said the company does not comment on pending litigation. "We remain committed to operating safely, responsibly, and in compliance with all applicable regulations," the spokesperson wrote in an email. The lawsuit is seeking damages for the alleged physical and mental harm caused by the leak, past and future medical expenses and lost wages. Lawson, a Harris County resident, is seeking over $1 million in damages, according to the lawsuit. Shortly after the leak, County Judge Hidalgo said during a news conference that two people were hospitalized and released, while 44 others were treated at the scene. Lawson was diagnosed with chemical exposure and inflammation of the lungs, according to the lawsuit. On Monday, BWC Terminals said in a statement that the majority of the sulfuric acid released went into a designated containment area, with an “unknown” amount entering the ship channel. The full extent of the possible environmental impact caused by the leak is currently unknown. No other lawsuits against BWC Terminals had been filed in Harris County as of Friday morning.

L.A. fire cleanups reports describe repeated violations, illegal dumping allegation

We reviewed thousands of pages of Army Corps of Engineering quality assurance reports for the January fire soil cleanup. The results were startling.

The primary federal contractor entrusted with purging fire debris from the Eaton and Palisades fires may have illegally dumped toxic ash and misused contaminated soil in breach of state policy, according to federal government reports recently obtained by The Times.The records depict harried disaster workers appearing to take dangerous shortcuts that could leave hazardous pollution and endanger thousands of survivors poised to return to these communities. The Federal Emergency Management Agency and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers allocated $60 million to hire personnel to monitor daily cleanup operations and document any health and safety risks. The Times obtained thousands of government oversight reports that detail these federal efforts to rid fire-destroyed homes of toxic debris between February and mid-May. The records, which were obtained on a rolling basis over several months, include dozens of instances in which oversight personnel flagged workers for disregarding cleanup procedures in a way that likely spread toxic substances. The latest batch of reports — turned over to The Times on Dec. 1 — contained allegations of improper actions involving Environmental Chemical Corp., the primary federal contractor, and the dozens of debris-removal crews it supervised. For example, on April 30, federally hired workers were clearing fire debris from a burned-down home in the Palisades burn scar. According to the Army Corps of Engineers, after the last dump truck left, an official with Environmental Chemical Corp., a Burlingame, Calif., company hired to carry out the federal debris removal mission, ordered workers to move the remaining ash and debris to a neighboring property.The crew used construction equipment to move four or five “buckets” worth of fire debris onto the neighboring property. It’s unclear if that property was also destroyed in the Palisades fire, and, if so, whether it had been already remediated.“I questioned if this was allowable and then the crew dumped material into the excavator bucket and planned to move it on the lowboy with material in bucket,” a federal supervisor wrote in a report intended to track performance of contractors. “Don’t think this is allowed.” According to the report, the workers also left glass, ash and other fire debris on the property the crew had been clearing, because they “were in a rush to get to the next site.” Experts who reviewed the reports said the behavior described may amount to illegal dumping under California law. Other reports obtained by The Times describe federal cleanup workers, on multiple occasions, using ash-contaminated soil to backfill holes and smooth out uneven portions of fire-destroyed properties in the Palisades burn scar. If that were true, it would be a breach of state policy that says contaminated soil from areas undergoing environmental cleanup cannot be used in this way. The reports also cite multiple occasions where workers walked through already cleared properties with dirty boot covers, possibly re-contaminating them. The inspectors also reported crews spraying contaminated pool water onto neighboring properties and into storm drains, and excavator operators using toothed buckets that caused clean and contaminated soil to be commingled.“Obviously, there was some really good work done,” state Sen. Ben Allen (D-Pacific Palisades) said about the federal cleanup. “But it appears that we’ve got some folks who are knowingly breaking the law and cutting corners in their cleanup protocol. “We’ve got to figure out how widespread this was, and anybody who was responsible for having broken a law in this area needs to be held accountable.” The Army Corps did not respond to requests for comment. An ECC executive said that without information such as the properties’ addresses or parcel numbers, he could not verify whether the accusations made in the oversight reports were substantiated by the companies’ own investigations or if any issues raised by the inspectors were resolved. Such specifics were redacted in the version of the reports sent to The Times. “At a high level, ECC does not authorize the placement of wildfire debris or ash on neighboring properties, does not permit the use of contaminated material as fill, and operates under continuous [Army Corps] oversight,” said Glenn Sweatt, ECC’s vice president of contracts and compliance.Between February and September, the Army Corps responded to nearly 1,100 public complaints or other inquiries related to the federal fire cleanup. Over 20% of grievances were related to quality of work, according to the Army Corps assessment of complaints. Some of these complaints point to the same concerns raised by the inspectors. For example, a resident in the Eaton burn scar filed a complaint on June 19 that “crews working on adjacent properties moved fire debris and ash onto his property after he specifically asked them not to.” Other property owners in Altadena filed complaints that crews had left all sorts of fire debris on their property — in some cases, buried in the ground. The Army Corps or ECC ordered crews to go back and finish up the debris removal for some properties. Other times, the officials left the work and costs to disaster victims. A Palisades property owner complained on May 7 that after the Army Corps supposedly completed cleaning his property, he found “parts of broken foundation [that] were buried to avoid full removal.” He said it cost him $40,000 to hire a private contractor to gather up and dispose of several dumpsters of busted-up concrete. James Mayfield, a hazardous materials specialist and owner of Mayfield Environmental Engineering, was hired by more than 200 homeowners affected by the fires to remove debris and contaminated soil — including, in some cases, from properties already cleared by Army Corps contractors. When Mayfield and his workers excavated additional soil from Army Corps-cleared properties, he said they occasionally uncovered ash, slabs of burned stucco, and other debris. “All you have to do is scoop and you can see the rest of the house underneath the ground,” Mayfield said. “It was never cleared at all.” After January’s wildfires, local health authorities warned the soil could be riddled with harmful pollutants from burned-down homes and cars, including lead, a heavy metal that can cause irreversible brain damage when inhaled or ingested by young children.Soil testing has been standard practice after major wildfires in California since 2007. Typically, after work crews clear away fire debris and several inches of topsoil from burned-down homes, federal or state disaster officials arrange for the same contractors to test the soil for lingering contamination. If they find contamination above state benchmarks, they are required to excavate another layer of that soil and conduct additional rounds of testing.But the aftermath of the Eaton and Palisades fires has been different. The Federal Emergency Management Agency has repeatedly refused to pay for soil testing in California, insisting the practice is not necessary to remove any immediate threats after the fires. The Newsom administration unsuccessfully petitioned FEMA to reconsider conducting soil testing to protect returning residents and workers. But as pressure mounted on the state to fund soil testing, the California Environmental Protection Agency secretary downplayed public health risks from fire contamination.Indeed, the vast majority of wildfire cleanups in California are managed by state agencies. Since the January wildfires, California officials have been noticeably guarded when questioned about how the state will respond when the next major wildfire inevitably strikes.Asked whether the state will continue to adhere to its long-standing post-fire soil sampling protocols, the California Governor’s Office of Emergency Services wouldn’t directly answer whether it would pay for soil testing after future wildfires. Its director, Nancy Ward, declined to be interviewed.“California has the most advanced testing systems in the nation, and we remain committed to advocating for the safe, timely removal of debris after a wildfire,” an agency spokesperson said in a statement. “Protecting public health and the well-being of impacted communities remains the state’s foremost priority.”Some environmental experts and lawmakers worry that abandoning long-established wildfire protocols, like soil testing, may set a precedent where disaster victims will assume more costs and work to ensure that their properties are safe to return to and rebuild upon.U.S. Rep. Brad Sherman (D–Los Angeles) called for the Army Corps to review the results of large-scale soil testing initiatives, including data from USC, to determine which contractors were assigned to clean properties where heavy contamination persists. Such an analysis, he said, might help the federal government figure out which contractors performed poor work, so that they they aren’t hired in future disasters. “I’m going to press the Army Corps to look at where the testing indicates there was still contaminants and who is the contractor for that, to see whether there are certain contractors that had a high failure rate,” Sherman said.“I want to make sure they’re ... evaluating these contractors vis-à-vis the next disaster,” he added. “And, ultimately it’s in the testing.”Throughout much of Altadena and Pacific Palisades, thousands of empty lots are awaiting permits to rebuild. But many property owners fear the possibility of contamination. The Department of Angels, a community-led nonprofit formed after the January wildfires, surveyed 2,300 residents whose homes were damaged or destroyed by the Eaton and Palisades blazes. About one-third of respondents said they wanted testing but had not received it.“The government abandoned testing and left us on our own,” one victim wrote. “We have each had to find out what is the best route to test and remediate, but without standardization and consistency, we are a giant experiment.”

These 10 Wellness Items Solve Real Problems And Won Our HuffPicks Award

After much deliberation, a famous foot stretcher, one cane-shaped massager and others have earned this shopping honor.

With each passing allergy season, major wildfire, and the latest EPA report on pollution, concern for air quality has and will continue to be a major factor in our health and wellness reporting. Based on former in-depth conversations with associate professor of otolaryngology at Stanford University Zara M. Patel and a respiratory therapist and member of the American Association for Respiratory Care Joyce Baker, air purifiers (and most importantly, the right air purifier) are one of the greatest defenses we have against poor indoor air quality, which “can be two to five times more polluted than outdoors because of the lack of fresh air, circulation and ventilation,” according to Baker (who cited an assessment from the Environmental Protection Agency).The decision to award BlueAir's blissfully quiet and top-performing 411i Max air purifier a HuffPick was the result of combined guidance from Baker and Patel and our very own personal experience. “[The] BlueAir 411 is remarkable because it just works — as soon as it’s on, you can feel the difference in the air, leaving air crisper and fresher," former HuffPost shopping writer Haley Zovickian previously said. It should be worth mentioning that, like myself, Zovickian lives in smog-filled Los Angeles, a city that was recently ravaged by one of the worst wildfires in recent history.“I no longer sneeze and itch from dust, pollen and who knows what, and my close friends with cat allergies are able to comfortably relax in my cat hair-filled room as long as the air purifier is on,” Zovickian said.Aside from its sleek Scandinavian-inspired design, Zovickian points to BlueAir's excellent filtration system that uses a dual HEPA filter, a washable fabric pre-filter and an active carbon filter to trap both large and tiny airborne particles like bacteria, viruses, dust, potentially harmful chemicals, and those responsible for odor.The purifier featured here is offers a slight upgrade from Zovickian's preferred model with its Wifi capability, which makes it easier to keep track of air quality and trends over time using the accompanying app, plus do things like schedule run times remotely and use voice commands. It also comes in three sizes, depending on the square footage of the space.

Indigenous groups fight to save rediscovered settlement site on Texas coast

Flanked by a chemical plant and an oil rig construction yard, the site on Corpus Christi Bay may be the last of its kind on this stretch of coastline, now occupied by petrochemical facilities.

Audio recording is automated for accessibility. Humans wrote and edited the story. See our AI policy, and give us feedback. This story is published in partnership with Inside Climate News, a nonprofit, independent news organization that covers climate, energy and the environment. Sign up for the ICN newsletter here. INGLESIDE — The rediscovery of an ancient settlement site, sandwiched between industrial complexes on Corpus Christi Bay, has spurred a campaign for its preservation by Native American groups in South Texas. Hundreds of such sites were once documented around nearby bays but virtually all have been destroyed as cities, refineries and petrochemical plants spread along the waterfront at one of Texas’ commercial ports. In a letter last month, nonprofit lawyers representing the Karankawa and Carrizo/Comecrudo Tribe of Texas asked the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to revoke an unused permit that would authorize construction of an oil terminal at the site, called Donnel Point, among the last undisturbed tracts of land on almost 70 miles of shoreline. “We’re not just talking about a geographical point on the map,” said Love Sanchez, a 43-year-old mother of two and a Karankawa descendent in Corpus Christi. “We’re talking about a place that holds memory.” The site sits on several hundred acres of undeveloped scrubland, criss-crossed by wildlife trails with almost a half mile of waterfront. It was documented by Texas archaeologists in the 1930s but thought to be lost to dredging of an industrial ship canal in the 1950s. Last year a local geologist stumbled upon the site while boating on the bay and worked with a local professor of history to identify it in academic records. For Sanchez, a former office worker at the Corpus Christi Independent School District, Donnel Point represents a precious, physical connection to a past that’s been largely covered up. She formed a group called Indigenous Peoples of the Coastal Bend in 2018 to raise awareness about the unacknowledged Indigenous heritage of this region on the middle Texas coast. The names and tales of her ancestors here were lost to genocide in Texas. Monuments now say her people went extinct. But the family lore, earthy skin tones and black, waxy hair of many South Texas families attest that Indigenous bloodlines survived. For their descendents, few sites like Donnel Point remain as evidence of how deep their roots here run. “Even if the stories were taken or burned or scattered, the land still remembers,” Sanchez said. The land tells a story at odds with the narrative taught in Texas schools, that only sparse bands of people lived here when American settlers arrived. Instead, the number and ages of settlement sites documented around the bay suggest that its bounty of fish and crustaceans supported thriving populations. “This place was like a magnet for humans,” said Peter Moore, a professor of early American history at Texas A&M University-Corpus Christi who identified the site at Donnel Point. “Clearly, this was a densely settled place.” There’s no telling how many sites have been lost, he said, especially to the growth of the petrochemical industry. The state’s detailed archaeological records are only available to licensed archaeologists, who are contracted primarily by developers. A few sites were excavated and cataloged before they were destroyed. Many others disappeared anonymously. Their remains now lie beneath urban sprawl on the south shore of Corpus Christi Bay and an industrial corridor on its north. “Along a coastline that had dense settlements, they’re all gone,” Moore said. The last shell midden Rediscovery of the site at Donnel Point began last summer when Patrick Nye, a local geologist and retired oilman, noticed something odd while boating near the edge of the bay: a pile of bright white oyster, conch and scallop shells spilling from the brush some 15 feet above the water and cascading down the steep, clay bank. Nye, 71, knew something about local archaeology. Growing up on this coastline he amassed a collection of thousands of pot shards and arrowheads (later donated to a local Indigenous group) from a patch of woods near his home just a few miles up the shore, a place called McGloins Bluff. Nye’s father, chief justice of the local court of civil appeals, helped save the site from plans by an oil company to dump dredging waste there in 1980. Later, in 2004, the Port of Corpus Christi Authority, which owned the tract, commissioned the excavation and removal of about 40,000 artifacts so it could sell the land to a different oil company for development, against the recommendations of archaeological consultants and state historical authorities. Patrick Nye pilots his boat on Corpus Christi Bay at daybreak on Dec. 7, 2025. Dylan Baddour/Inside Climate News“We’re not going to let that happen here,” Nye said on a foggy morning in December as he steered his twin engine bay boat up to Donnel Point, situated between a chemical plant and a construction yard for offshore oil rigs on land owned by the Port of Corpus Christi Authority. Nye returned to the site with Moore, who taught a class at Texas A&M University about the discovery in 1996 and subsequent destruction of a large cemetery near campus called Cayo del Oso, where construction crews found hundreds of burials dating from 2,800 years ago until the 18th century. It now sits beneath roads and houses of Corpus Christi’s Bay Area. Moore consulted the research of two local archaeologists, a father and son-in-law duo named Harold Pape and John Tunnell who documented hundreds of Indigenous cultural sites around nearby bays in the 1920s, ‘30s and ‘40s, including a string of particularly dense settlements on the north shore of Corpus Christi Bay. Their work was only published in 2015 by their descendents, John Tunnell Jr. and his son Jace Tunnell, both professors at A&M. Moore looked up the location that Nye had described, and there he found it — a hand-drawn map of a place called Donnel Point, with six small Xs denoting “minor sites” and two circles for “major sites.” A map produced by Pape and Tunnell showing Donnel Point, then called Boyd’s Point, in 1940, with several major and minor archaeological sites marked. Used with permission. Tunnell, J. W., & Tunnell, J. (2015). Pioneering archaeology in the Texas coastal bend : The Pape-Tunnell collection. Texas A&M University Press.The map also showed a wide, sandy point jutting 1,000 feet into Corpus Christi Bay, which no longer exists. It was demolished by dredging for La Quinta Ship Channel in the 1950s. Moore’s research found a later archaeological survey of the area ordered by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in the 1970s concluded the sites on Donnel Point were lost. “Subsequent archeological reports repeated this assumption,” said an eight-page report Moore produced last year on the rediscovery of the sites. The artifacts at Donnel Point are probably no different than those collected from similar sites that have been paved over. The sites’ largest features are likely the large heaps of seashells, called middens, left by generations of fishermen eating oysters, scallops and conchs. “Even if it’s just a shell midden, in some ways it’s the last shell midden,” Moore said at a coffee shop in Corpus Christi. “It deserves special protection.” Nye and Moore took their findings to local Indigenous groups, who quietly began planning a campaign for preservation. Seashells spilling down the edge of a tall, clay bank, 15 feet above the water, on Dec. 7, 2025. Dredging for an industrial ship channel and subsequent erosion cut into these shell middens left by generations of indigenous fishermen. Dylan Baddour/Inside Climate NewsA mistaken extinction Under the law, preservation often means excavating artifacts before sites are paved over. But the descendents of these coastal cultures are less concerned about the scraps and trinkets their ancestors left behind as they are about the place itself. In most cases they can only guess where the old villages stood before they were erased. In this rare case they know. Now they would like to visit. “Not only are we fighting to maintain a sacred place, we’re trying to maintain a connection that we’ve had over thousands and thousands of years,” said Juan Mancias, chair of the Carrizo/Comecrudo Tribe of Texas, during a webinar in November to raise awareness about the site. The destruction of these sites furthers the erasure of Indigenous people from Texas, he said. He has fought for years against the planned destruction of another village site called Garcia Pasture, which is slated to become an LNG terminal at the Port of Brownsville, south of Corpus Christi. North of Corpus Christi, near Victoria, a large, 7,000-year-old cemetery was exhumed in 2006 for a canal expansion at a plastics plant. “The petrochemical industry has to understand that we’re going to stand in the way of their so-called progress,” Mancias, a 71-year-old former youth social worker, said during the webinar. “They have total disregard for the land because they have no connection. They’re immigrants.” He grew up picking cotton with other Mexican laborers in the Texas Panhandle. But his grandparents told him stories about the ancient forests and villages of the lower Rio Grande that they’d been forced to flee. His schooling and history books told him the stories couldn’t be true. They said the Indigenous people of South Texas vanished long ago and offered little interest or insight into how they lived. It was through archaeological sites that Mancias later confirmed the places in his grandparents’ stories existed. There is no easy pathway for Mancias to protect these sites. Neither the Carrizo/Comecrudo or the Karankawa, who inhabited the coastal plains of Texas and Tamaulipas, are among the federally recognized tribes that were resettled by the U.S. government onto reservations. Only federally recognized tribes have legal rights to archaeological sites in their ancestral territory. As far as U.S. law is concerned, the native peoples of South Texas no longer exist, leaving the lands they once occupied ripe for economic development. “Now it’s the invaders who decide who and what we are,” said Mancias in an interview. “That’s why we struggle with our own identities.” Juan Mancias, chair of the Carrizo/Comecrudo Tribe of Texas, at an H-E-B grocery store in Port Isabel in 2022. Dylan Baddour/Inside Climate NewsIn Corpus Christi, the story of Indigenous extinction appears on a historical marker placed prominently at a bayside park in commemoration of the Karankawa peoples. “Many of the Indians were killed in warfare,” it says. “Remaining members of the tribe fled to Mexico about 1843. Annihilation of that remnant about 1858 marked the disappearance of the Karankawa Indians.” That isn’t true, according to Tim Seiter, an assistant professor of history at the University of Texas at Tyler who studies Karankawa history. While Indigenous communities ceased to exist openly, not every last family was killed. Asserting extinction, he said, is another means of conquest. “This is very much purposefully done,” he said. “If the Karakawas go extinct, they can’t come back and reclaim the land.” Stories of survival Almost a century before the English pilgrims landed at Plymouth Rock, the Spaniard Cabeza de Vaca lived with and wrote about the Karankawas — a diverse collection of bands and clans that shared a common language along the Gulf Coast. By the time Anglo-American settlers began to arrive in Texas, the Karankawas were 300 years acquainted with Spanish language and culture. Some of them settled in or around Spanish missions as far inland as San Antonio. Many had married into the new population of colonial Texas. Many of their descendants still exist today. “We just call those people Tejanos, or Mexicans,” said Seiter, who grew up near the Gulf coast outside Houston. Love Sanchez with her mother and two sons at a park in Corpus Christi in 2022. Dylan Baddour/Inside Climate NewsHe made those connections through Spanish records at archives in San Antonio. In Texas’ Anglo-American era, Seiter said, most available information about the Karankawas comes from the diaries of settlers who are trying to exterminate them. Some of the last stories of the Karankawas written into history involve settler militias launching surprise attacks on Karankawa settlements and gunning down men, women and children as they fled across a river. “The documents are coming from the colonists and they’re not keeping tabs of who they are killing in these genocidal campaigns,” Seiter said. “It makes it really hard to do ancestry.” All the accounts tell of Karankawa deaths and expulsion. Stories of survivors and escapees never made it into the record. But Seiter said he’s identified individuals through documents who survived massacres. Moreover, oral histories of Hispanic families say many others escaped, hid their identities and fled to Mexico or integrated into Anglo society. That’s one reason why archaeological sites like Donnel Point are so important, Seiter said: They are a record that was left by the people themselves, rather than by immigrant writers. The lack of information leaves a lot of mystery in the backgrounds of people like Sanchez, founder of Indigenous Peoples of the Coastal Bend in Corpus Christi. She was born in Corpus Christi to parents from South Texas and grandparents from Mexico. Almost 20 years ago her cousin shared the results of a DNA test showing their mixed Indigenous ancestry from the Gulf Coast region. Curious to learn more, she sought out a local elder named Larry Running Turtle Salazar who she had seen at craft markets. Salazar gained prominence and solidified a small community around a campaign to protect the Cayo del Oso burial ground. Through Salazar, Sanchez learned about local Indigenous culture and history. Then she was jolted to action after 2016, when she followed online as Native American protesters gathered on the Standing Rock Lakota Reservation to block an oil company from laying its pipeline across their territory. The images of Indigenous solidarity, and of protesters pepper sprayed by oil company security, inflamed Sanchez’s emotions. She began attending small protests in Corpus Christi. When Salazar announced his retirement from posting on social media, exhausted by all the hate, Sanchez said she would take up the task fighting for awareness of Indigenous heritage. “People don’t want us to exist,” she said beneath mesquite trees at a park in Corpus Christi. “Sometimes they are really mean.” In 2018 she formed her group, Indigenous Peoples of the Coastal Bend, which she now operates full time, visiting schools and youth groups to tell about the Karankawa and help kids learn to love their local ecosystems. Over time the group has become increasingly focused on environmental protection from expansion of the fossil fuel industry. Salazar died in March at 68. Chemours Chemical plant on La Quinta Ship Channel, adjacent to the site of Donnel Point in 2022. Dylan Baddour/Inside Climate NewsProtecting Donnel Point When Nye and Moore shared their discovery with Sanchez, who has always dreamed of becoming a lawyer, she knew it had to be kept secret while a legal strategy was devised, lest the site’s developers rush to beat them. The groups brought their case to nonprofit lawyers at Earthjustice and the University of Texas School of Law Environmental Clinic, who filed records requests to turn up available information on the property. “We discovered that they had this old permit that had been extended and transferred,” said Erin Gaines, clinical professor at the clinic. “Then we started digging in on that.” The permit was issued in 2016 by USACE to the site’s previous owner, Cheniere, to build an oil condensate terminal, then transferred to the Port of Corpus Christi Authority, administrator of the nation’s top port for oil exports, when it bought the land in 2021. Since then, the Port has sought developers to build and operate a terminal in the space, the lawyers found, even though proposed layouts and environmental conditions differ greatly from the project plans reviewed for the 2016 permit. In November, Sanchez and the other groups announced their campaign publicly when their lawyers filed official comments with USACE, requesting that the permit for the site be revoked or subject to new reviews. The Port of Corpus Christi Authority did not respond to a request for comment. “Cultural information and environmental conditions at the site have changed, necessitating new federal reviews and a new permit application,” the comments said. “Local residents and researchers have re-discovered an archaeological site in the project area, consisting of a former settlement that was thought to be lost and is of great importance to the Karankawa and Carrizo/Comecrudo Tribes.” Still, the site faces a slim shot at preservation. First it would need to be flagged by the Texas Historical Commission. But the commissioners there are appointed by Gov. Greg Abbott, who has received $40 million in campaign contributions from the oil and gas industry since taking office. Even then, preservation under the law means digging up artifacts and putting them in storage so the site can be cleared for development. Only under exceptional circumstances could it be protected in an undisturbed state. Neither Abbott’s office nor the Texas Historical Commission responded to a request for comment. Despite the odds, Sanchez dreams of making Donnel Point a place that people could visit to feel their ancestors’ presence and imagine the thousands of years that they fished from the bay. The fossil fuel industry is a towering opponent, but she’s used to it here. She plans to never give up. “In this type of organizing you can lose hope really fast,” she said. “No one here has lost hope.” Disclosure: H-E-B, Texas A&M University, Texas A&M University Press and Texas Historical Commission have been financial supporters of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan news organization that is funded in part by donations from members, foundations and corporate sponsors. Financial supporters play no role in the Tribune’s journalism. Find a complete list of them here.

Suggested Viewing

Join us to forge
a sustainable future

Our team is always growing.
Become a partner, volunteer, sponsor, or intern today.
Let us know how you would like to get involved!

CONTACT US

sign up for our mailing list to stay informed on the latest films and environmental headlines.

Subscribers receive a free day pass for streaming Cinema Verde.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.